Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Q&A

Chair Menin Questions DOT on Low Approval Rates and Application Backlogs

New York City Council · Apr 23, 2025 · starts 1:35:45 · 2 min 37 sec

Chair Julie Menin questions DOT on why only 67 businesses have received full approval, challenging the agency's claim that the program is going well.

Julie Menin

Because the goal of the hearing is obviously to try to fix this backlog and figure out what we can do to improve this.

Julie Menin

Why is it that only 67 businesses have received this full approval?

Margaret Forgioni

Okay, I'll start out by going through some of the numbers and then Michelle will add if I've I've missed anything.

Margaret Forgioni

First and foremost, we want to emphasize that 80% of the program's applicants are now able to be up and running as of April 1st.

Margaret Forgioni

So the bottom line is that 80% of restaurants can operate as we speak.

Margaret Forgioni

So that for us is the most key factor here.

Margaret Forgioni

We want to get every restaurant operational as soon as possible.

Julie Menin

So does that give restaurants a certainty that they need?

Julie Menin

They're outlaying a lot of expenses on this.

Julie Menin

Good.

Margaret Forgioni

So let me explain that a little bit.

Margaret Forgioni

And maybe I'll run through some of the numbers, Chair, if that's good, and then I'll get your question.

Margaret Forgioni

So we've had 3,922 total applications, and that is from about 3,200 different food service establishments.

Margaret Forgioni

Of those applications, 774 are roadway, 1754 are sidewalk, and 697 are both.

Margaret Forgioni

Of that group of applications, we have 511 that were either withdrawn by the applicant or were denied because they were in a bus stop or they were at a hydrant or something of that nature.

Margaret Forgioni

So that leaves us with about 3,411.

Margaret Forgioni

Of that 3,411, 2,603 are able to operate either because they have gone through the process, or if their sidewalk they applied between before August 3rd, or if their roadway, they've gone through so much of the process that we know their application is correct and they've already had a public hearing.

Margaret Forgioni

So to answer your question, the people that have been able to set up now, roadway in particular, we have completely reviewed every aspect of their application and they're all correct.

Margaret Forgioni

So they won't be in the situation where they've set something up, and then upon the final license, we're gonna say, Oh, what you put out there is incorrect.

Margaret Forgioni

That that will not happen.

Margaret Forgioni

They know exactly what they need to put out.

Margaret Forgioni

In the meantime, we have the 1800 sidewalk setups also operating, and we've been very clear with all of them that they should do so, and that we'll keep working through the process in the meantime.

Julie Menin

What happens to the 20%?

Margaret Forgioni

So the 20%, let me tell you about that exactly.