Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Public Testimony

Mary Kathleen Collins Testimony: West Village Resident

New York City Council · Apr 23, 2025 · starts 3:44:42 · 2 min 44 sec

Mary Kathleen Collins, a West Village resident, testifies via Zoom to oppose outdoor dining due to safety, cleanliness, and the obstruction of emergency vehicle access on narrow streets.

Member of the Public - Mary Augustine

It's regarding safety, cleanliness, and people being able to get by on the sidewalk.

Member of the Public - Mary Augustine

Uh I'm against any waivers or roadside dining, hook and ladders cannot put their feet down to uh they can move cars, but they can't move the platforms or anything that is in the roadway uh barriers, I think it is, to do that.

Member of the Public - Mary Augustine

We had two uh an elderly couple who died on Sullivan Street.

Member of the Public - Mary Augustine

They were burnt to death.

Member of the Public - Mary Augustine

So the West Village residents, Mary, Augustine, Leslie, then there was John Grimes and Peter Davies from another group uh who testified I agree with them.

Member of the Public - Mary Augustine

It is uh dirty, rat infested, the garbage storage, and I've been going to the CB2 meetings, the restaurants.

Member of the Public - Mary Augustine

Dot is has been very confusing because the program was rolled out quickly.

Member of the Public - Mary Augustine

These meetings are hours long and over successive days in a week, and it's a tremendous amount to ask of us.

Member of the Public - Mary Augustine

I worked in the restaurant during COVID.

Member of the Public - Mary Augustine

I am immune compromised, and now I also have a disability.

Member of the Public - Mary Augustine

So the sidewalk issue is even more important.

Member of the Public - Mary Augustine

Um the restaurants never follow the guidelines.

Member of the Public - Mary Augustine

There is not a one.

Member of the Public - Mary Augustine

The one that I worked for paid attention very closely, but it's still not on mark.

Member of the Public - Mary Augustine

I live in the village.

Member of the Public - Mary Augustine

Uh this is not outdoor dining hall.

Member of the Public - Mary Augustine

You shouldn't have weddings outside, because what happens is they take over the sidewalk.

Member of the Public - Mary Augustine

I live on Cornelia Street.

Member of the Public - Mary Augustine

It's a very small space, and this happens all the time.

Member of the Public - Mary Augustine

And then there have been restaurants that are in the queue with CBT and haven't gotten a time has expired for sidewalk dining or for roadway dining, but they were doing a lot of things.

Member of the Public - Mary Augustine

Okay, I'm sorry, Mary, you have to wrap up.

Member of the Public - Mary Augustine

Thank you, Mary.

Member of the Public - Mary Augustine

Thank you.

Member of the Public - Mary Augustine

Thank you very much.

Julie Menin

Okay, Mary, that's why I have to do it.

Julie Menin

I'm sorry, Mary, your time is up.

Julie Menin

Sorry, Mary, your time is up.

Julie Menin

Thank you.

Julie Menin

Safety first.

Julie Menin

Okay, I don't think she can hear, so we need to.

Julie Menin

Okay.

Julie Menin

Thank you, Mary.

Julie Menin

Thank you very much.

Julie Menin

And our next speaker is Kathleen Collins.

Council Staff

You may be good.

Member of the Public - Kathleen Collins

Good afternoon.

Member of the Public - Kathleen Collins

My name is Kathan Collins, and I'm a uh lifetime New Yorker.