Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Menin on grocery pricing model and basket of goods

New York City Council · May 29, 2026 · starts 4:35:23 · 2 min 38 sec

Menin asks how groceries will be priced and what's in the core basket. Peck explains a third-party operator will run stores normally, with the city covering tenant fit-out, rent, and property tax to subsidize a core basket of fresh foods.

Julie Menin

How much are the groceries going to cost?

Jeanne Peck

Well, the grocery, you mean in terms of the discount?

Julie Menin

Yeah.

Jeanne Peck

Okay, so how we're doing this is that we're going to, in the summer, we're going to put out an RFI for a third-party operator, city grocery operator.

Jeanne Peck

And through that structure, they're going to be operating the grocery store like a normal grocery store.

Jeanne Peck

And we're going to have in that RFI.

Jeanne Peck

A core basket of goods that will be discounted.

Jeanne Peck

What we're offering the operator is the city paying the tenant fit out.

Jeanne Peck

So the substantial cost of the grocery operator would normally have to pay.

Jeanne Peck

They are not going to have to pay rent and then

Jeanne Peck

Property tax.

Jeanne Peck

So we're going to ensure that that subsidy directly goes to the food affordability of those core baskets.

Jeanne Peck

And then we're going to work out all the details.

Jeanne Peck

Once the RFE comes out, you'll see some of the details.

Jeanne Peck

And then ongoing negotiations with the city operator.

Jeanne Peck

It might be one.

Jeanne Peck

It might be multiple.

Julie Menin

A couple questions.

Julie Menin

So what are the basket of goods that will be covered?

Julie Menin

What's included in that?

Jeanne Peck

So we're still working that out, but the focus is fresh, healthy foods and everyday groceries.

Jeanne Peck

So think bread, milk, meat, chicken, eggs.

Julie Menin

And how...

Jeanne Peck

Produce.

Julie Menin

Given that...

Julie Menin

I understand the concept of they're going to not have to pay rent and there'll be reduced costs, but that given that they're not going to be able to volume purchase, which other grocery stores are able to, how will these

Julie Menin

government-run stores be able to drive the cost down in that regard, on the purchasing side?

Jeanne Peck

So these are going to be third-party operators that already have grocery stores that they run.

Jeanne Peck

So whatever model that they have to operate, they will still be operating through that model.

Jeanne Peck

It's not going to be like a separate model.

Julie Menin

Understood.

Julie Menin

And then how many New Yorkers will they be able to reach?

Julie Menin

Like, in other words, the Hunts Point and the La Maricata site, what does EDC's projections say in terms of the reach of each of the respective stores?

Jeanne Peck

I'm sorry, can you say that, Council?

Jeanne Peck

Yes, yeah.

Julie Menin

So for the Hunts Point and the La Maricata site, what is the...

Julie Menin

the reach that EDC is estimating.

Julie Menin

I mean, how many New Yorkers are going to be able to shop there, purchase a basket of good, like what is the actual reach?

Jeanne Peck

Yeah, we're not gonna limit it.

Jeanne Peck

It's going to be like a regular grocery store so people can come and shop.

Jeanne Peck

And so it'll be people for the neighborhood, but people who are coming from other places as well.

Jeanne Peck

We want to increase the foot traffic because as you said, you know, we want the neighborhood to thrive through the,

Jeanne Peck

New York City grocery store being located there.