Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

CM Restler on constituent case management and DOHMH responsiveness

New York City Council · Jun 5, 2026 · starts 3:26:43 · 3 min 38 sec

Restler expresses frustration with DOHMH's limited assistance for constituents with severe mental health issues, citing a case of an individual screaming in a park for two years. Martin and Nichols acknowledge the frustration, noting HIPAA limits on sharing information but pledging to problem-solve with OCS.

Lincoln Restler

And then I just want to take a moment to also ask about

Lincoln Restler

our challenges in coordinating with the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene regarding constituents with severe mental health issues.

Lincoln Restler

There is, when we reach out, there is, I would describe it as very limited assistance is provided.

Lincoln Restler

We're told to call for a mobile crisis team, which maybe tries to visit once, then there's no follow-up.

Lincoln Restler

The Department of Health will not engage with us or provide any updates or solutions that may have been provided to the individual who we're calling about.

Lincoln Restler

The individuals continue to endanger their own safety and

Lincoln Restler

safety of members of our community.

Lincoln Restler

It happens again and again and again.

Lincoln Restler

And I just, I don't, at this point, I don't even think it's worth calling the Department of Health.

Lincoln Restler

I just, it doesn't help.

Lincoln Restler

It makes no difference.

Lincoln Restler

So I'm just trying to figure out how can we partner more effectively.

Lincoln Restler

We have an individual with severe mental health challenges screaming in a park for hours every day.

Lincoln Restler

For now two years.

Lincoln Restler

It's been a daily, almost probably five days a week, hours on end, often drunk, screams nasty, threatening things at neighbors,

Lincoln Restler

I just like, what are we, is DOHMH able to help on a situation like that?

Lincoln Restler

Because we haven't gotten any help yet.

Dr. Alistair Martin

Let me ask just a follow-up question, Councilmember.

Dr. Alistair Martin

Is this for individuals who are slotted for supportive housing, or are these individuals?

Lincoln Restler

No, no, no.

Lincoln Restler

These are just people who are struggling with mental illness around my community who are causing serious issues.

Lincoln Restler

I get no help.

Lincoln Restler

I mean, I try.

Lincoln Restler

I call everyone I can in the agency.

Lincoln Restler

It doesn't make a difference.

Lincoln Restler

I get no help.

Lincoln Restler

And this has been the case for years.

Lincoln Restler

And I just am so frustrated and disappointed that I, it's like, it feels like I have to take the health department off as one of the resources to go to because it doesn't yield to outcomes.

Lincoln Restler

It doesn't actually make a difference.

Lincoln Restler

And I certainly get no updates because we get no, nothing is shared with me.

Lincoln Restler

It's just deeply, deeply frustrating.

Lincoln Restler

And is there any, in that example, is there anything the health department can do to help?

Dr. Alistair Martin

Yeah, first of all, I hear you, we hear you, and thank you for flagging this.

Dr. Alistair Martin

You know, moving forward, this is the kind of work that we're trying to, in an interagency way with OCS, really be able to

Dr. Alistair Martin

address and so we're eager to try to do some problem solving around this.

Dr. Alistair Martin

Let me see if Jamie do you have anything else you want to add?

Jamie Nichols

Yeah, I'm sorry you feel that way.

Jamie Nichols

It's frustrating on our side too because there's a lot that we do but we can't

Jamie Nichols

share a person's protected health information back with you.

Jamie Nichols

So we really appreciate the referrals and the situations that you bring to our attention.

Jamie Nichols

We act on them.

Jamie Nichols

I know that.

Jamie Nichols

I see the information.

Jamie Nichols

But we can't talk about a person's treatment plan with a third party.

Lincoln Restler

I totally understand their HIPAA restrictions, but we don't see any improvement on the ground.

Lincoln Restler

Like, we don't see change.

Lincoln Restler

We don't, and without getting into specifics about somebody's exact treatment plan, I don't need to know that information.

Lincoln Restler

I do want to know we're actively engaging with this person, we've been connecting them to help, we're involved, that we're making a difference, that we're in a sustained way continuing to engage here.

Lincoln Restler

anything so that we can come back to our constituents and say, hey, we're trying, the health department's engaged, we're doing something, and I just get a brick wall and I see no difference in the outcomes, so it just feels like nothing's happening and I can't see the result.

Lincoln Restler

So I don't advocate for these things, I don't even call anymore because I honestly feel like what's the point?