Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

CM Restler on offline supportive housing units and repair costs

New York City Council · Jun 5, 2026 · starts 3:55:20 · 3 min 48 sec

Restler revisits supportive housing vacancies with updated April 30th data showing 486 units offline or with no referral. He presses on repair costs for 381 offline units; Nichols says costs are borne by landlords and providers, not visible to DOHMH. Restler pushes for solutions to bring units online.

Lincoln Restler

Great, thank you so much.

Lincoln Restler

I want to apologize, I was looking at the report from November, and in fact the report, the most recent report is from April 30th, so just to go through it, in November there was a combined 465 units that were offline

Lincoln Restler

or online with no referral in process.

Lincoln Restler

As of April 30th, there's 486 units that are either offline, supportive housing units under DOHMH's control, that are either offline or with no referral in process.

Lincoln Restler

So let's try again on those.

Lincoln Restler

So for the 381 that are currently offline, do you have an average cost of repair to bring that unit back online?

Lincoln Restler

I recognize it's a fluid dynamic.

Lincoln Restler

I recognize that things are changing.

Lincoln Restler

But just so that we could try to ballpark some resources to invest to help bring those units online, because I think we all want to see every one of those units online, right?

Lincoln Restler

Thank you, Jamie.

Lincoln Restler

What would, do you have a ballpark estimate per unit for the renovation costs?

Jamie Nichols

I don't have that information.

Lincoln Restler

Can you provide that to us?

Jamie Nichols

The repair, the majority, I don't know if I can, the majority of repair costs would be borne by the landlord.

Jamie Nichols

Our relationship is with the service provider.

Jamie Nichols

Sometimes those are the same entity, but oftentimes they're not.

Jamie Nichols

So we're not seeing those costs.

Jamie Nichols

Those are low.

Lincoln Restler

Those are for scatter site units or congregate.

Lincoln Restler

The landlord and the provider are the same, right?

Jamie Nichols

Not always.

Lincoln Restler

So you don't have a contractual model through the provider to be able to do repairs or upgrades when a unit's offline?

Jamie Nichols

There's a small amount of money in our contracts with the service providers to address minor repairs.

Jamie Nichols

Could amendments be made if there were resources?

Jamie Nichols

My guess is that these ones that are offline have much more significant repairs, and that's why they're offline.

Jamie Nichols

So routine painting and stuff, that's covered in our service contract.

Lincoln Restler

Could amendments be made to those contracts to put additional resources in to fix up the units, or are we just stuck with a few hundred?

Lincoln Restler

Maybe.

Jamie Nichols

I mean, I think this is a, yeah, how can we get...

Lincoln Restler

All right, maybe ask the question, how do you want to fix up the offline units?

Lincoln Restler

What's your proposal to do it?

Jamie Nichols

I think that's less of a health question.

Jamie Nichols

I think we'd really want to talk to the construction people on that.

Lincoln Restler

But these are units within your control that are empty, right, and offline, and that we desperately need people living in.

Lincoln Restler

You know, from April 30th to November 30th, just a six-month period.

Lincoln Restler

But in that period, the number of offline...

Lincoln Restler

units didn't change from 387 to 381.

Lincoln Restler

We don't want to just be getting the next report in six months that there's 379 offline units and that we haven't done anything either.

Lincoln Restler

So any ideas that you can share with us at this hearing for resources where resources could be brought to bear to bring those units back online?

Dr. Alistair Martin

So I think, Councilmember, we're eager to do some problem solving with you on this.

Dr. Alistair Martin

Clearly, there are tools on the table for us to do this.

Dr. Alistair Martin

And so, you know, we'd be looking forward to bringing those tools to bear to solve this problem.

Lincoln Restler

The Progressive Caucus is actively...

Lincoln Restler

Discussing with City Hall and with OMB resources that we want to invest in the budget to bring these units online.

Lincoln Restler

It is, in my opinion, disgraceful that we're funding 1,000 city supportive housing units between DOHMH and HRA, so they have even more than you guys, that are not...

Lincoln Restler

Filled with people when we have thousands of folks sleeping on the streets with serious mental illness who desperately need help we know this is the evidence-based approach the cost-effective approach to making a difference in people's lives we want to put resources in this budget that activates every one of these units so that

Lincoln Restler

at the next budget hearing a year from now when we're doing this all over again we're talking about how we got that number dramatically down and so

Lincoln Restler

there's two weeks left three weeks three weeks and change left before we're voting on a budget there isn't a lot of time so if you have suggestions you want to share with us let us know but we're pushing for resources and we'll push for our best ideas unless you want to share any with us

Lincoln Restler

Thank you.

Dr. Alistair Martin

Thank you, Councilman.

Tiffany L. Cabán

Okay, great.

Tiffany L. Cabán

Back over to Chair Coburn.

Tiffany L. Cabán

Thank you.