Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

De La Rosa questions audit findings on technical control weaknesses

New York City Council · Jun 24, 2026 · starts 2:18:50 · 3 min 32 sec

De La Rosa asks about confidential weaknesses in system monitoring, unsupported systems, and firewalls identified in the comptroller's audit. DOE officials confirm changes have been made or are planned but decline to disclose specifics for security reasons. De La Rosa presses for status updates on each recommendation.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Okay, I want to move on to my other questions, but I am interested in hearing what steps since 2024, what changes you've made besides saying something different in the Chancellor's regulations and sending out more emails in Principles Digest is being done to do this

Carmen N. De La Rosa

critical training that was identified in the Comptroller's report, the audit.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

The audit also identified weaknesses in DOE's technical controls that were not disclosed publicly because they were confidential, correct?

Member of the Public - Dennis

Yes, that's right.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

So is the DOE in a position today to share more information about those weaknesses and what it's done to remediate them?

Member of the Public - Dennis

I don't believe we're in the position to disclose.

Member of the Public - Dennis

I think part of the reason why that portion of the audit report was kept confidential is because there's information in there that could potentially jeopardize our information technology assets.

Member of the Public - Dennis

Security posture.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Like your mom's made a name last four of your social and first pet's name?

Member of the Public - Dennis

Something like that.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Something like that.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

But what that means to me also,

Carmen N. De La Rosa

I'll say the audit states the weaknesses involved system monitoring, unsupported systems, and firewalls, correct?

Member of the Public - Dennis

Yes, that's right.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

And have any changes been made to your systems to improve system monitoring and firewalls and other unsupported systems?

Member of the Public - Dennis

I could defer to DIT on that, as far as I know that work is underway.

Member of the Public

The answer is yes.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

The changes have been made or we're talking about doing the work?

Member of the Public

Both.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Tell me more.

Member of the Public

I don't really want to go too far past what has already been disclosed with the areas.

Member of the Public

And this is...

Member of the Public

This is common practice in a security, the security side of an audit, that some of the information is not disclosed, disclosed publicly.

Member of the Public

But it was disclosed to us, and to the extent that we said, yes, we agree, and could make the technical changes to improve security, we've either planned to do that or have done it.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

So this, again, this is a report, I just...

Carmen N. De La Rosa

From 2024, and they're in a confidential report, you just shared that there were specific recommendations made in the confidential report.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

In those two years, in addition to whatever changes that you are implementing,

Carmen N. De La Rosa

outside of the recommendations.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

In those two years, have you implemented the recommendations made by the controller's report?

Member of the Public - Dennis

Sorry, can I just interject?

Member of the Public - Dennis

Please.

Member of the Public - Dennis

What is the 2024 date that you're referring to?

Carmen N. De La Rosa

I have a report.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

The data was from 2024 in the report.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

I apologize.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

So how many of those?

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Yeah, so, Chair, please, thank you.

Member of the Public

I'll try to parse this because I would like to be able to answer the question.

Member of the Public

Yes, thank you.

Member of the Public

But let's say there were five or six recommendations.

Member of the Public

Without disclosing specifically what they were, I think it would be appropriate for us to look at those and provide back as much information as we can about the status of each one of those.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Yeah.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

And I think, I mean, this is all part of a pattern, right?

Carmen N. De La Rosa

I mean, everyone from the DOE.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

And the council, I think we care a lot about the same things, but what we're interested in is the implementation of a policy that keeps our kids safe and keeps our kids learning.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

So I want to turn over second round to...