Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Sanchez questions DOT on lighting options mounted on elevated rail structures

New York City Council · Jun 25, 2026 · starts 0:26:30 · 2 min 51 sec

Councilmember Sanchez asks about installing lights on the elevated rail itself rather than street poles, citing examples from cities worldwide. Dean explains vibration issues, the trains' own power systems, and coordination challenges with NYC Transit make this atypical, but says he would check if it has been studied.

Justin E. Sanchez

Yes, I do.

Justin E. Sanchez

So if you look around the world, if you go to Santiago, Santo Domingo, if you go to Puerto Rico, Chicago, Bangkok, Kuala Lumpur, Miami,

Justin E. Sanchez

The list goes on.

Justin E. Sanchez

Seoul, Dubai.

Justin E. Sanchez

All of these places around the world have lights specifically on their train rail system.

Justin E. Sanchez

I'm curious to know if there is an opportunity that doesn't include lighting on actual the street light poles, but on the elevated rail itself.

Justin E. Sanchez

And what is preventing anyone from adding lights to that elevated rail itself?

Monty Dean

We typically don't because there are vibration issues.

Monty Dean

There's also they have their own power on the train lines that we'd have to contend with.

Monty Dean

So there may be instances where we've done it, but it's not the typical practice.

Monty Dean

Oh, it can be challenging.

Monty Dean

It's, you know, for us, it's typically easier because we own and operate the streets and we have usually have some form of existing light poles there that we can add on to.

Monty Dean

So if, for instance, adding a pole on the back of an existing light pole is adding an arm on an existing light pole is an option that that's typically easier to do.

Justin E. Sanchez

So is it accurate to say that the street lighting on rails would be more of a state issue than it is a city issue because of the control of the elevated subways?

Monty Dean

We would certainly have to work with them in those instances because they do own the infrastructure.

Monty Dean

So in those scenarios, we'd have to coordinate definitely with New York City Transit.

Justin E. Sanchez

Has there been any assessment of using the power that already exists on the trains to illuminate the underneath?

Justin E. Sanchez

I mean, the way that I envision Councilmember Henry's, Thomas Henry's bill is, I mean, we have lights that you can literally just stick onto a wall with batteries.

Justin E. Sanchez

Then that was when I was a kid.

Justin E. Sanchez

And so seeing the way that technology has.

Justin E. Sanchez

Vastly improved now.

Justin E. Sanchez

I'm curious to know if there are green ways and

Justin E. Sanchez

green infrastructure ways that we can be adding light that uses the renewable electricity that already exists on these train tracks to help illuminate underneath.

Justin E. Sanchez

Is there been any ability to study that or any discussions with either state partners or other city partners about doing something in that way?

Justin E. Sanchez

Have you been able to envision this legislation in that way at all?

Monty Dean

I'm not aware that that has been studied, so we'd have to check and see if that's something that's been looked at before.

Justin E. Sanchez

Okay.

Justin E. Sanchez

Thank you.

Shaun Abreu

All right.