Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

CM Dinowitz asks panel about city steps to shift burden from co-op shareholders

New York City Council · Aug 18, 2026 · starts 1:04:18 · 2 min 5 sec

Dinowitz asks what the city could do to put the burden on government rather than individual shareholders. Poole says state legislation needs amendment, and Haber suggests taking the list offline and inverting the process so government must demonstrate tax liability.

Eric Dinowitz

So beyond state legislation, which you've mentioned, what steps could the city take?

Eric Dinowitz

Because I think you're right.

Eric Dinowitz

I think the burden should be on the government, not on the individual shareholder or homeowner to address the costs.

Eric Dinowitz

And in particular, in the case of co-ops, it should certainly not be in the burden should not be on individual shareholders who aren't wouldn't otherwise be subject to this tax.

Eric Dinowitz

So what steps should the city be taking to the city government be taking to put the burden on them regarding co-ops?

Eric Dinowitz

Can we have the mic on, please?

Member of the Public - Rebecca Poole

The state legislation sets up the chart of evaluations and it sets up the process as it is now

Member of the Public - Rebecca Poole

where the Department of Finance

Member of the Public - Rebecca Poole

can bill the, can have the co-op be the collector for them.

Member of the Public - Rebecca Poole

So I think we have to work very hard to amend, for amendments to the state law as soon as the state legislature reconvenes, or the new legislature convenes in January.

Member of the Public - Rebecca Poole

I don't know, I can't think of specifics that we could do here

Member of the Public - Rebecca Poole

without the right state legislation to help with the implementation of this difficult law.

Member of the Public - Rebecca Poole

Correct me if I'm wrong.

Member of the Public - Jason Haber

I would just add that I would invert, if I had a magic wand, I would get the list off the internet immediately.

Member of the Public - Jason Haber

Right?

Member of the Public - Jason Haber

I would invert the whole process and allow for the enormity of government to be required to tax the citizens and demonstrate it not the other way around.

Member of the Public - Jason Haber

I think those basic steps would cure a lot of confusion.

Member of the Public - Jason Haber

And would be fair.

Member of the Public - Jason Haber

And I think that's a step in the right direction.

Member of the Public - Mary Ann Rothman

Thank you so much.

Member of the Public - Mary Ann Rothman

Thank you, Chair.

Member of the Public - Mary Ann Rothman

Thank you.