Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Ida Goldstein testifies about husband Robert's death from Legionnaires

New York City Council · Sep 2, 2026 · starts 0:26:04 · 2 min 49 sec

Ida Goldstein, married 50 years, describes her husband Robert's two-week hospitalization on life support before dying from Legionnaires contracted through their home window. She calls the death preventable through proper cooling tower cleaning.

Lynn C. Schulman

who are members of the community and victims of Legionella and have, and are family members of victims, so we don't want to keep them here too long.

Lynn C. Schulman

We have, the first one we have is virtual Ida Goldstein.

Council Staff

You can begin.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

Good morning.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

My name is Ida Goldstein.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

Now, I'll tell you, Robert was an Air Force veteran and a successful businessman, and he graduated with a Juris Doctorate degree from New York Law School.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

I was by his side every day in the hospital, walking back and forth every day.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

Legionnaire came into my home window.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

I am concerned for my safety and anyone else.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

Bottom line, it could have been avoided easily by having the water towers cleaned.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

He caught an pneumonia and had a high fever of 104.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

Robert was exposed to this poison.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

Being in the hospital for over two weeks, he kept declining.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

He was on life support and oxygen.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

His lungs weren't working well.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

His kidneys shut down.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

He was on antibiotics and brain imaging.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

His white blood cells increased.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

He was going in and out of consciousness.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

I was waiting every day to see if he would improve, but he kept getting worse.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

He was getting thinner every day.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

My heart was breaking watching him suffer with all this life support attached to his body.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

This water vapor that he breathed in with no warning came in our own home from the outside.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

It took his life away.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

And from coming into our privacy of our own home, it murdered him and destroyed me.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

We are married 50 years and my loss of him is tremendous.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

He really fought for his life in every possible way because he said to me, I don't want to leave you.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

I am lost without you.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

He was my everything, my soulmate, the love of my life.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

There will never be another one like him.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

I was privileged to have him in my life, a true love story, and I don't have him anymore.

Lynn C. Schulman

Are you done or do you?

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

Yes, I'm done.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

I'm hard.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

Okay, thank you so much.

Lynn C. Schulman

I'm so sorry for your loss.

Lynn C. Schulman

Thank you very much for your testimony.

Lynn C. Schulman

Much appreciated.

Member of the Public - Ida Goldstein

Thank you.