Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Remarks

Joseph argues moment of silence is not enough and urges statewide 9/11 curriculum

New York City Council · Sep 9, 2026 · starts 0:04:41 · 1 min 23 sec

Joseph argues that a moment of silence is not enough—curriculum teaches. She notes that today's teachers and students weren't alive for 9/11, references existing NYC DOE resources and museum visits, and calls for statewide legislation so children in Buffalo and Rochester learn this history with the same seriousness as those in Brooklyn.

Rita C. Joseph

New York already requires moment of silence in our schools each September 11th.

Rita C. Joseph

That matters, but a moment of silence is not a lesson plan.

Rita C. Joseph

Silence remembers, curriculum teaches.

Rita C. Joseph

My generation of teachers didn't need a curriculum to explain that day, we lived it.

Rita C. Joseph

And we improvised because we had to.

Rita C. Joseph

But the teachers standing in front of the classrooms today weren't there, neither were their students.

Rita C. Joseph

If we don't require this history to be taught deliberately and well, it simply won't be.

Rita C. Joseph

Not due to a lack of care, but because people who remember it firsthand were getting fewer every year.

Rita C. Joseph

New York City has tried to close that gap.

Rita C. Joseph

Our Department of Education built 911 curriculum resources with the Memorial Museum, and this council funded students'visit to the museum this year.

Rita C. Joseph

But a child in Buffalo or Rochester deserves to learn this history with the same seriousness as a child in Brooklyn.

Rita C. Joseph

That's statewide responsibility.

Rita C. Joseph

State lawmakers have introduced legislation to do exactly that.

Rita C. Joseph

Firefighter Joseph Spar Jr., who responded to Rescue 3 that morning and never came home.

Rita C. Joseph

Resolution 7A tells Albany that the City Council stand behind that effort.

Rita C. Joseph

I want to thank my colleagues for years of working and keeping this history alive, for the generation that wasn't there to witness it.

Rita C. Joseph

I urge my colleague to vote yes.

Rita C. Joseph

I urge Albany to act.

Rita C. Joseph

Thank you.