Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Muhammad Karuma (Youth Alliance for Housing) on COPA as essential legislation

New York City Council · Sep 9, 2026 · starts 5:00:18 · 3 min 29 sec

Karuma, a lifelong Bronxite, describes 217 violations in his building in one year and argues the housing crisis is total, pressing on every household. He urges the committee to lead by passing COPA, giving community organizations a real say in building management.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

Thank you.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

Good afternoon, everyone.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

Good afternoon, Chair Sanchez and members of the Housing Committee.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

My name is Muhammad Karuma.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

I'm a lifelong Brock site.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

I'm a tenant in Melrose, and I'm a member of the Youth Alliance for Housing.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

Together with them, I've begun organizing with my neighbors to struggle for repairs and against rising costs.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

I came here today prepared to describe to the committee a number of the 217 violations my building has had in the last year alone, but it felt trite.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

I wanted to bring to you descriptions of the burden our rents place on my neighbors, but that itself felt tired.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

It felt cliche.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

Because at the end of the day, ours is not a unique challenge or even a particularly severe one by the standards of the Bronx.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

Something like it is happening everywhere in our neighborhoods and in our borough.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

Furthermore, something like it is happening all across the city.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

The housing crisis is total.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

It consumes this city and it consumes this country.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

It places a pressure on every household in our city.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

It presses on them like a pinched nerve.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

We ask ourselves as we look at the news why it is that it seems the times are so crazy, why it seems Americans are acting out so much.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

We must ask ourselves what pressures.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

Americans today are under.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

And we must ask ourselves what government can do to alleviate these pressures and what might happen if it fails in that duty.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

COPA means that bodies dedicated to, first and foremost, to affordable housing will get the first say in purchasing these buildings.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

Organizations administered directly by the tenants can administer necessary repairs, can cohere tenants together,

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

and build communities.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

It means our communities will have a real say in the management of our homes, that they won't be managed by someone who has no real tie to our communities, no real tie to our neighborhoods.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

And it may set an example that other American cities may follow at a time in which an example must be set when the housing crisis is only getting worse and it presses on.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

Almost every aspect of American life these days.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

I came here to ask the committee to lead, to pass this essential legislation, and to stay vigorous in attempting to find a solution to the housing crisis.

Member of the Public - Muhammad Karuma

Thank you very much.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Thank you so much.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Right on time.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

And folks from Sponey, thank you for coming in.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

It's good to see you outside of the Zoom box.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

I hope you appreciated some of the shout-outs today.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Just appreciate your feedback and look forward to more conversation.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Thank you all for your testimony.

Member of the Public - Ilan Rabinovich

Thank you.

Member of the Public - Ilan Rabinovich

And I just, you know, from our last conversation, just a reminder, the most important thing you could do to solve the cost of housing in New York, reform property tax.

Member of the Public - Ilan Rabinovich

It's our largest expense, and it's what makes everything so difficult.

Member of the Public - Ilan Rabinovich

Thank you.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Thank you.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Thank you.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Can I get a quick show of hands from the audience if you plan to testify?

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Please keep your hand up.

Council Staff

We just want to count the minutes.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Thank you so much.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

The next panel.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Oksana Miranova, Judith Kanepa, Ariel Hirsch, Will Spisak.