Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Hanif questions alternative routing models and restoring public trust

New York City Council · Sep 9, 2026 · starts 1:48:35 · 3 min 19 sec

Hanif asks about researching what other cities do for backup routing and independent entities outside the police department. She also asks how the city plans to address distrust in the 911 system. Gelobter commits to looking at alternative routes, learning from other cities, and restoring trust through the root cause analysis and NextGen 911 implementation.

Shahana K. Hanif

And then I know I just ran out, but I have two questions.

Shahana K. Hanif

Chairs, if you'll allow me.

Shahana K. Hanif

I would love to know, as you're thinking about...

Shahana K. Hanif

Like, you know, if this happens again, we can't go hours and then just expect, well, we're going to come back online after however many hours.

Shahana K. Hanif

But rather, are you all thinking about what other cities have done in terms of including independent and other?

Shahana K. Hanif

Entities outside of the department, police department, for these calls to be able to be rerouted or there's a backup that once a system is shutting down,

Shahana K. Hanif

and like we're so advanced with technology that yeah, if one system is shutting down, there should be no

Shahana K. Hanif

quams about another system going up within minutes.

Shahana K. Hanif

So would love to

Shahana K. Hanif

to hear a little bit about what you're researching, and I highly recommend that we look into what other cities are doing.

Shahana K. Hanif

And then two, how does the city plan to address the distrust in the 911 system after this outage?

Shahana K. Hanif

And thank you, chairs.

Lisa Gelobter

Thank you for that question.

Lisa Gelobter

As we do the root cause analysis, one of the other things that we will absolutely have to look into is what are the options.

Lisa Gelobter

So not just for alerting and alarming, not just for notification of the public, but what are alternative routes or options where some of these calls might have been able to be handled.

Lisa Gelobter

So that we will absolutely be looking into that as we do this root cause analysis.

Lisa Gelobter

And to your point, I think it's well taken that we should...

Lisa Gelobter

Look at what other systems across the U.S.

Lisa Gelobter

Are doing, and that is we are in communication with other emergency services organizations throughout the country.

Lisa Gelobter

So we will absolutely do that.

Lisa Gelobter

In terms of addressing the distrust, what I can commit to at this point is this is obviously

Lisa Gelobter

a critical service and New Yorkers need to be able to trust that they can call 911 and be answered, get their calls answered.

Lisa Gelobter

We need to restore that trust.

Lisa Gelobter

We need to make sure that this type of issue does not reoccur.

Lisa Gelobter

And that is what I'm committing to doing.

Lisa Gelobter

That means not just doing the root cause analysis, but also figuring out how we do implement NextGen 911 in a way that is timely as well as robust.

Lisa Gelobter

So that is something that I am committed to doing.

Lisa Gelobter

Immediately.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Thank you.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

We're going to turn it back.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Well, before I do that, I want to recognize that we've been joined by Councilmember Riley and Councilmember Wan.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

And we're going to turn it back to Chair Felice for a second round.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Well, the chair is the chair, so we...

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Majority leader?

Carmen N. De La Rosa

It's a tie?

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Okay.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

I'll pick my favorite Dominican.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

I'm just kidding.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Majority leader, Abreu.