Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Public testimony: Jessica opposes tower, cites tree removal and backyard impact

New York City Council · Sep 9, 2026 · starts 2:16:12 · 1 min 37 sec

Jessica, a ground-floor resident at 2128 45th Road whose backyard backs up to TD Bank, opposes the tower scale. She notes the developer already removed a tree covering her yard without notice and prefers a lower, more residential building with community give-backs.

Farah N. Louis

Hello, this is Jess.

Farah N. Louis

Hello.

Farah N. Louis

Okay, we'll start with Jessica.

Farah N. Louis

Are you ready?

Farah N. Louis

Oh, great.

Member of the Public - Jessica

Yeah, sorry about that.

Farah N. Louis

No problem.

Farah N. Louis

You may begin.

Member of the Public - Jessica

Hi.

Member of the Public - Jessica

So I'm in 2128 45th Road along with Melissa.

Member of the Public - Jessica

I'm on the ground floor, though.

Member of the Public - Jessica

My backyard backs up to the TD Bank.

Member of the Public - Jessica

And similar to what everyone else was saying, you know, it does block.

Member of the Public - Jessica

That's one kind of aesthetic thing.

Member of the Public - Jessica

But I think from, you know, the point of view of how the neighborhood functions and...

Member of the Public - Jessica

who's going to be coming there and how, you know, we want to be able to give back to the neighborhood.

Member of the Public - Jessica

If it were a lower building, more residential in nature, along with some, you know, piece of give back, that would really be useful.

Member of the Public - Jessica

And also having the connection to PS1 right there.

Member of the Public - Jessica

It just seems like such a high tower doesn't seem to fit within.

Member of the Public - Jessica

The neighborhood aesthetic.

Member of the Public - Jessica

You know, that aside from the fact that our backyard backs up to the TD Bank, they've already pulled out a tree that covered our yard that was quite beautiful without telling us, which obviously it's not our tree, but it was unfortunate.

Member of the Public - Jessica

And I just, you know, don't want to see a huge building back there for the rest of our lives.

Member of the Public - Jessica

So that's all I have to say.

Member of the Public - Jessica

I'm at work currently, so I had to take a little time out to do this, but think it's really important.

Member of the Public - Jessica

So thank you.

Farah N. Louis

Thank you for making time, Jessica.