Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Public testimony: Melissa Guan shows balcony view of low-rise neighborhood context

New York City Council · Sep 9, 2026 · starts 2:09:41 · 2 min 11 sec

Melissa Guan, a homeowner at 2128 45th Road, shows her balcony view via camera demonstrating the low-rise character of the block. She points out the TD Bank lot, the 11-story Prime building on Jackson Avenue, and the four-to-five story buildings that make up the immediate neighborhood.

Farah N. Louis

Melissa Guan.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

Hi, everybody.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

Can you hear me?

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

This is Melissa.

Farah N. Louis

Yes, we can hear you.

Farah N. Louis

You may begin.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

Yeah, this is Melissa Guan.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

I live in 21, 28, 45th Road, which is the part that was not addressed during this discussion that our building is right to the north of this plant.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

And I'm actually on my balcony right now.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

I'll just quickly show everybody how it looks like on my balcony.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

So this is our balcony.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

This is our building.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

Every building adjacent to us, there's six exact buildings like ours.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

And that one over there is the older building that is shorter.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

This is the 11-story building.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

See how tall it is?

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

That is a prime.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

And then going this way,

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

You can see everybody in this block is a low rise and everybody have a backyard.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

And this is our building.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

This is a four floor tall.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

The whole building, including that new building, building the next block is only five stories.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

Everybody here is four or five stories.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

And if you can see the very tall building that's cited by the developer,

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

Over there,

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

That is across the street in that corner.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

This whole building, this whole block is low rise.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

You can see that's the PS3.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

Now you have a clear view of this whole block.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

That is not our block.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

The prime building that's above Trader Joe's, you can see that's 11th story.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

That's not our block.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

That belongs to the Jackson Avenue.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

So I think speaking about this with this picture view, if you guys can see, I think it's more powerful than anything I say other than that.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

We are all invested families in this neighborhood.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

Many of these buildings are not renters.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

Like we cannot easily move away because there's a building going to be built right in front of my face right here at this TD lot.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

You can see this is the TD lot right here.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

We're not moving away.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

We invested our life savings in this building.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

The same with all the six buildings, each have six units.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

And all the other neighborhoods were different than our building, but it's of the same height.

Member of the Public - Melissa Guan

That's my testimony.