Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Remarks

CM Carr opposes Chokshi for Board of Health, citing vaccine mandate record

New York City Council · Sep 10, 2026 · starts 0:13:18 · 1 min 9 sec

Carr opposes Dr. Chokshi's appointment to the Board of Health, calling him a leading architect of the city employee vaccine mandate that caused workers to lose their livelihoods, and arguing his stance that the mandate saved lives sets a dangerous precedent for public health mandates on the Board.

David M. Carr

Unfortunately, I cannot say the same for the other two.

David M. Carr

Dr.

David M. Carr

Chokshi is one of the leading architects of the city employee mandate system.

David M. Carr

That caused so many city workers to not only lose their livelihoods, but the careers to which they were passionately attached.

David M. Carr

And based on his testimony at the hearing we held earlier this month, he remains steadfast in support of that decision, one that simply isn't supported by the science, despite the fact that

David M. Carr

It's clear that the vaccine mandate did not do anything to stop the spread.

David M. Carr

He still maintains that it was the right decision because of the lives that it saved.

David M. Carr

This is a dangerous precedent for a person to serve on the Board of Health to have because essentially what he's saying is that any public health mandate that could be

David M. Carr

life-saving or health-saving to the individual is justified.

David M. Carr

Public health mandates are only justified when you seek to protect others from the health care decisions made by or not made by other individuals.

David M. Carr

So I think this is not a position of someone who should be on the Board of Health.