Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Celeste Elias testifies on inability to refuse iPads and iReady assessments

New York City Council · Sep 15, 2026 · starts 4:01:35 · 2 min 8 sec

Celeste Elias, a kindergarten parent, describes being unable to refuse iPads or iReady assessments despite privacy lawsuits, receiving no response from administrators, and discovering her child was given access to scary TikToks on a teacher's personal phone in pre-K.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

Hi, my name is Celeste.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

I'm a kindergarten parent.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

I emailed the school at the start of the summer about my objections to one-to-one iPads and hours-long iReady assessments, of which are exempt from the current screen time bans for lower elementary grades.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

IReady is currently being sued for deceptive marketing and data privacy violations, but I was still told I couldn't refuse an iPad or iReady assessments, nor could I request a paper alternative.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

The principal explained iPads are only used for a short time, but refusing one is impossible to integrate it into daily curriculum.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

She didn't see the contradiction.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

The school and district did not provide anything in writing.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

I emailed Paulo Perdomo a face on August 6th and 27th requesting support and to see written policies governing parent refusal of assessments.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

I received no response.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

I sent a letter of religious exemption for all devices and assessments to the superintendent and principal on August 28th.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

I received no response.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

The new policies do not address the DOE's failure to protect student data privacy as exposed in the state's audit and the power school data breaches.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

Nor does it clear up parental rights to choose when children are introduced to devices or the internet.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

In pre-K, a teacher gave my child her personal phone to play games at nap time and access social media.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

He said he was watching scary TikToks about skinwalkers.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

She admitted to giving him her personal phone.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

I did not feel my concerns were taken seriously by the school admin.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

I emailed the superintendent and again received no response.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

A mother spoke at a pep meeting stating sexual content and a website to make weapons were fully accessible on her child's school device.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

She received no resolution.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

So why should I trust the district or city to protect my child when he's again given a device against my wishes?

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

I know firsthand what a complete failure devices are because I was issued an iPad as a student.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

We consistently got around safety restrictions.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

Utah State Audit found 52% of school apps violated data privacy agreements, and 36% of those shared student data with ad companies.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

Is this data harvesting of our kids lawful and ethical?

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

The only ethical and democratic solution is for schools to implement opt-in policies and obtain informed revocable parental consent.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

There is no reason to give children access to the internet or a device outside of a tech class other than to let companies profit off and test products on our children.

Member of the Public - Celeste Elias

I did not consent for my child to be part of an ed tech experiment.

Member of the Public - Hilary Kong

Can you hear me okay?