Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Krishnan questions DOE on banning gamified apps beyond AI policy

New York City Council · Sep 15, 2026 · starts 2:18:20 · 1 min 52 sec

Krishnan asks if DOE will commit to banning gamified apps the way it blocked YouTube, noting these apps existed before AI and may not be caught by the AI moratorium. Giunta says gamified apps are not what DOE envisions but takes it under advisement.

Shekar Krishnan

Yeah, thank you.

Shekar Krishnan

And, you know, and I think a number of the things we heard today, it sounds.

Shekar Krishnan

like you've been thoughtful about, and making it public, putting it on the website, I think would make a lot of students and teachers and families feel more at ease.

Shekar Krishnan

I want to go back to the gamified apps for a second.

Shekar Krishnan

This is, these are really damaging to our kids, much in the same way that social media could be.

Shekar Krishnan

You're always looking for the next dopamine hit, right?

Shekar Krishnan

And they take so much of the learning out of these gamified apps.

Shekar Krishnan

You've committed to banning YouTube for the younger students, blocking it from their student accounts.

Shekar Krishnan

Is that same commitment going to be made for these gamified apps?

Danielle Giunta

We will take it under advisement, but a lot of these are going to end up being subject to either our AI moratorium or perhaps not, you know,

Danielle Giunta

I'm not sure which ones we're talking about, you know, specifically, but I do think we're going to see a very limited use.

Danielle Giunta

I don't, you know, gamified apps is not something that we really want to see in our schools.

Danielle Giunta

That is not really the intentional instructional use of technology that we're envisioning.

Shekar Krishnan

Yeah, I will note that before the advent of AI, these sorts of apps existed, right?

Shekar Krishnan

So beyond the AI policy, beyond it happening, it happens to be caught up in your AI policy, maybe, and it may not be.

Shekar Krishnan

And so it's important to take a look at that and make sure, as I've been saying, what's going in front of our children is actually beneficial to our kids and supported by research.