Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Narcisse asks who enforces recommended screen time limits and what happens if schools don't comply

New York City Council · Sep 15, 2026 · starts 1:57:52 · 2 min 43 sec

Narcisse asks who is responsible for ensuring schools stay under the limits and what happens if they don't. Giunta reiterates the limits are non-negotiable despite being called recommendations, and describes feedback loops with superintendents and school visits.

Mercedes Narcisse

The caps for grade three through eight.

Mercedes Narcisse

Are described as recommended.

Mercedes Narcisse

Who is responsible for making sure a school stays under them?

Mercedes Narcisse

And what happens if a school does not?

Danielle Giunta

Yeah, thank you.

Danielle Giunta

This is back to the conversation earlier around the use of the word recommended versus mandate.

Danielle Giunta

We want to make sure that

Danielle Giunta

You know, I know words matter, so we can argue that mandate would have mattered as much as recommended.

Danielle Giunta

We also know that sometimes mandate leads to a punitive result.

Danielle Giunta

We did not want to make this.

Danielle Giunta

first year of this massive shift in our system, feel punitive or anyone to feel under pressure.

Danielle Giunta

We want to really support our schools in scaling down and paring back how much screen time they're using and how much access to AI, generative AI, that they're using in their schools.

Danielle Giunta

You know, as the first deputy chancellor, underneath me again are our superintendents and all of our schools.

Danielle Giunta

We're working in lockstep.

Danielle Giunta

We have incredible feedback loops.

Danielle Giunta

Some of them are formal, where we get on calls with our superintendents to check the pulse.

Danielle Giunta

I think you know the chancellor and I love to be in schools, and so do our superintendents.

Danielle Giunta

And we'll be using our school visits to gauge how this is going and course correcting, you know, in...

Danielle Giunta

In ways that might be necessary if we come across something.

Danielle Giunta

We learned so much through the cell phone policy that we have implementation of that because these were some of the questions that came up as we launched the cell phone policy as well.

Danielle Giunta

And our schools blew it out of the park with their ability to implement this cell phone policy with fidelity.

Danielle Giunta

And when issues came up, you know, we followed, like, for our students who were really insisting they needed their phone, access to the phone, or finding those great workarounds that are brilliant.

Danielle Giunta

children know how to do, that we're using a more progressive discipline approach than going straight to.

Danielle Giunta

And we want to take the same concept as we implement this this year.

Danielle Giunta

If for some reason we get word of a school, we'll support them through stronger implementation.

Danielle Giunta

And if we get to the point where we really are like, okay, we've done recommended enough, let's like we need to double down on the word mandate going forward, like that is a place that we are willing to evolve and grow.

Danielle Giunta

And again, it was so much community feedback that led us to this policy, and we are not done listening to the community.