Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Chair Thomas-Henry and panelists discuss nuances of convening the IBZ Boundary Commission

New York City Council · Sep 16, 2026 · starts 1:58:21 · 3 min 9 sec

Thomas-Henry asks for clarity on the panel's position about convening the commission. Tober, Archibald, and Lewis explain they support the legislation's reforms but believe convening is risky right now, with Archibald warning developers are already inquiring about residential conversion in IBZ areas.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

Thank you.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

I have a question or just a point of clarity.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

Lacey, you mentioned convening the commission may be too risky, but then it sounds like you guys are in favor of the commission.

Member of the Public - Lacey Tober

Of the revisions proposed in this legislation.

Member of the Public - Lacey Tober

I think there's a nuance.

Member of the Public - Lacey Tober

It's like convening the commission is not really something that we need to do right now.

Member of the Public - Lacey Tober

And I think we're worried that if we were to do that, given the makeup of the commission, even with these changes, there might be a push to shrink the zones.

Member of the Public - Lacey Tober

And that's the opposite of what we want to do.

Member of the Public - Lacey Tober

However, in the case that the commission were to be convened, this legislation will help.

Member of the Public - Lacey Tober

With making sure that they're looking at a robust set of criteria for any changes.

Member of the Public - Lacey Tober

It adds appointees from outside of the administration.

Member of the Public - Lacey Tober

That might end up being a check on that effort, depending on the admin's priorities.

Member of the Public - Lacey Tober

So it's yes, but.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

Anyone else want to give input into the pros and cons of the legislation?

Member of the Public - Leah Archibald

Yeah, I agree.

Member of the Public - Leah Archibald

I think it's...

Member of the Public - Leah Archibald

Not time.

Member of the Public - Leah Archibald

There isn't a reason right now, I think, to convene the Boundary Revision Commission.

Member of the Public - Leah Archibald

But I really like the ideas to broaden the representation and raise the bar to pulling pieces out of the industrial business zones.

Member of the Public - Leah Archibald

And I will also just like share this bit.

Member of the Public - Leah Archibald

of neighborhood intel, you know, since the Department of City Planning released their industrial action plan and,

Member of the Public - Leah Archibald

you know, kind of raised the question about the future of industrial business zones, they sent a message to the real estate market.

Member of the Public - Leah Archibald

My office is getting visits.

Member of the Public - Leah Archibald

From developers asking us how we would feel about residential in just a little corner of the industrial business zone.

Member of the Public - Leah Archibald

And so I think we're going to be seeing private applications come through.

Member of the Public - Leah Archibald

Asking for residential conversion in the industrial business zones, and it's going to beg the question, like, what now?

Member of the Public - Leah Archibald

What is our commitment moving forward as a city?

Member of the Public - Leah Archibald

So I think this legislation takes a step to try and prepare us for that, but I can tell you the developers are...

Member of the Public - Leah Archibald

On their way in.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

And just to add to that, to shout out both Councilmember Gutierrez and all of the IBSPs who really did a lot of advocacy from the draft to the final version of that plan to convey that

Shanel Thomas-Henry

they wanted to see changes and to see their districts protected and were able to be successful with that.

Member of the Public - Leah Archibald

Got it.

Member of the Public - Leah Archibald

All right.

Member of the Public - Leah Archibald

This panel is excused.

Member of the Public - Leah Archibald

Thank you.

Member of the Public - Leah Archibald

We will.