Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Rabia Khalid testifies for APNA Community Services on enrollment barriers

New York City Council · Sep 18, 2026 · starts 3:23:55 · 2 min 18 sec

Rabia Khalid of APNA Community Services, serving South Asian Muslim immigrant communities, describes how limited English proficiency, digital literacy barriers, and complex household structures compound enrollment challenges, and urges meaningful multilingual navigation support, reduced documentation burdens, and formal roles for community-based organizations.

Member of the Public - Rabia Khalid

Good afternoon.

Member of the Public - Rabia Khalid

My name is Rabia, and I am the program coordinator at APNA Community Services.

Member of the Public - Rabia Khalid

APNA serves South Asian Muslim immigrant, refugee, limited English proficient, older adult, and low-income communities across New York City.

Member of the Public - Rabia Khalid

Through our work in benefits navigation, case management, senior services, housing assistance, health care, food access, tax preparation, domestic violence support, and other social services, we regularly see how administrative barriers affect access to programs like screen and drink.

Member of the Public - Rabia Khalid

Eligible older adults and families can be lost on multiple points in the process from initial awareness and application to documentation, agency review, recertification, and renewals.

Member of the Public - Rabia Khalid

For the communities APNA serves, these challenges are often compounded by limited English proficiency, digital literacy barriers, cultural and ethnic backgrounds, disability, complex household structures, and unfamiliar

Member of the Public - Rabia Khalid

Unfamiliarity with the government and systems.

Member of the Public - Rabia Khalid

Addressing under-enrollment requires stronger program design across the full enrollment and retention process.

Member of the Public - Rabia Khalid

First, language access should include meaningful navigation support.

Member of the Public - Rabia Khalid

Translated forms are important, but many residents also need assistance understanding documentation requirements, household income rules, deficiency notices, and renewal procedures.

Member of the Public - Rabia Khalid

For many South Asian and older adults, effective access may require multilingual benefit navigation in commonly spoken languages with trained staff who can assist residents from application through recertification.

Member of the Public - Rabia Khalid

Second, the city should reduce unnecessary documentation burden.

Member of the Public - Rabia Khalid

And third, recertification should be designed around continuity for eligible residents.

Member of the Public - Rabia Khalid

The city should also consider the realities of multi-generational households.

Member of the Public - Rabia Khalid

Community-based organizations should also have a formal role in their enrollment systems.

Member of the Public - Rabia Khalid

Organizations like APNA already help residents interpret notices, and expanding this role requires dedicated funding, training, and referral protocols, and clear pathways for case escalation.

Member of the Public - Rabia Khalid

Finally, the city should measure where residents are being lost in the process.

Member of the Public - Rabia Khalid

Thank you for your time.

Member of the Public - Rabia Khalid

I will submit the written testimony.

Linda Lee

Thank you.