Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Dr. Steve Auerbach of Health Justice for New York calls for enforcement

New York City Council · Sep 22, 2026 · starts 2:25:55 · 2 min 56 sec

Dr. Steve Auerbach of Health Justice for New York says the audit shows sanctuary laws need actual enforcement and consequences for violators, including DOC and NYPD. He supports S.4814, calls on Senator Schumer to whip votes, and urges pressure on private hospitals to obey laws.

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

Hi, I'm Dr.

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

Steve Auerbach with Health and Justice for New York.

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

Thank you for having us again in front of this committee.

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

Wish it wasn't so necessary.

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

We have supported in the past on 2025 in 214, 1268, 1272, and 1412.

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

And earlier this year, 55 and 261.

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

And of course, the New York Trust Act and 395 and 396, which I think we'll be getting new numbers.

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

We support all of those.

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

And of course, the mayor's executive order 13.

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

What has been shown with the audit is that there needs to be actual enforcement, including consequences, for persons who violate existing sanctuary laws and the executive order.

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

That needs to include...

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

And it is politically tough, but it needs to include if you're going to actually have law enforcement equal under the law for everybody,

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

members of DOC, NYPD, et cetera, who violate existing statute and executive order.

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

Number one.

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

Number two, we support, of course, S-4814.

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

We call on our joint Senator Schumer to use his powers majority.

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

leader to whip the handful of Democrats who have not signed on to it, including in our neighbor, Connecticut.

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

We also co-wrote with Attorney General James and feel very proud of the New York State Law Legislature Safe Access to Care Act that was mentioned earlier.

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

It is carried by Rivera S10494 and AM Forest A11537.

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

And we would call on both passage in the New York State Legislature and perhaps a copycat legislation at the city level.

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

And finally, I really want to call upon, and this is my main message, I want to call upon the city council and the mayor to use

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

whatever means necessary, whether it's the bully pulpit or calling stakeholders together to involve the...

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

Private voluntary hospitals, whether it's individually or through their group, the Greater New York Hospital Association, Hospital Association, State of New York, to also obey these laws.

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

Senior management at some of those hospitals, including their boards of directors, include MAGA supporters, and they have been very reticent

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

to follow New York City and New York state law, and there needs to be consequences.

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

There are levers, including zoning, taxes, and licensing of facilities.

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

licensing that can be brought to bear if they're non-cooperative.

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

We need enforcement.

Member of the Public - Steve Auerbach

Thank you for your time.