Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Isabel Ortega Romero testifies on immigrant contributions and sanctuary compliance

New York City Council · Sep 22, 2026 · starts 1:30:41 · 1 min 21 sec

Isabel Ortega Romero says New York City is home to 3.1 million immigrants who make up 38% of the population and paid $74.8 billion in taxes in 2024. She says immigrants live in fear and that the audit revealed many city agencies were not complying with sanctuary laws.

Member of the Public - Isabel Ortega Romero

There we go.

Member of the Public - Isabel Ortega Romero

Thank you, Chair Encarnacion and members of the committee for holding this hearing today.

Member of the Public - Isabel Ortega Romero

My name is Isabel Ortega Romero, and I'm here representing the Brooklyn Borough President Antonio Reynoso.

Member of the Public - Isabel Ortega Romero

New York City is home to 3.1 million immigrants, 38% of the city's population.

Member of the Public - Isabel Ortega Romero

The city is built by immigrants.

Member of the Public - Isabel Ortega Romero

Immigrants comprise 43% of our workforce, and in 2024 alone, immigrant New Yorkers paid $74.8 billion in taxes.

Member of the Public - Isabel Ortega Romero

However, immigrants are far more than the labor they provide.

Member of the Public - Isabel Ortega Romero

They are our neighbors, friends, community members and leaders, and family.

Member of the Public - Isabel Ortega Romero

New York City is a sanctuary city, but its people are living in fear that going outside might lead to permanent separation from their loved ones.

Member of the Public - Isabel Ortega Romero

ICE arrested more people this July than in any other month during President Trump's second term.

Member of the Public - Isabel Ortega Romero

Recently, the administration's audit of city agencies revealed that many city agencies were not in compliance with sanctuary city laws.

Member of the Public - Isabel Ortega Romero

We commend the mayor for conducting this audit and agree with its recommendations.

Member of the Public - Isabel Ortega Romero

And we need more.

Member of the Public - Isabel Ortega Romero

Meaningful and reliable oversight of agencies'compliance with sanctuary city laws must be independent and ongoing.

Member of the Public - Isabel Ortega Romero

Because sanctuary city laws are only as strong as their enforcement, and allowing city agencies to unlawfully cooperate with ICE erodes trust in city government.