Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Remarks

Cabán and JJ Cleo Mizrahi discuss faith, family rejection, and trans visibility

New York City Council · Sep 23, 2026 · starts 2:47:41 · 2 min 27 sec

Cabán appreciates Mizrahi's comments about faith and saving a life. Mizrahi describes growing up in the Orthodox Jewish community, family rejection, internalized negative messages, and says the trans community remains on guard and fearful until Trumpism ends.

Tiffany L. Cabán

Thank you.

Tiffany L. Cabán

And I just want to take a moment to say I appreciate what you said about your faith.

Tiffany L. Cabán

One of the things I love about the Jewish faith is the idea that none of us is beyond redemption.

Tiffany L. Cabán

And yeah, when you save a life, you save the world.

Tiffany L. Cabán

And going beyond that, I think about the way that these institutions have capitulated.

Tiffany L. Cabán

And another part of the Jewish faith is like, you don't sacrifice it.

Tiffany L. Cabán

It's like we get there together or we don't get there at all.

Tiffany L. Cabán

And so I think it's really, really powerful that you all are here and making it clear that.

Tiffany L. Cabán

that's the case.

Tiffany L. Cabán

And so I'm really proud to be fighting with y'all.

Tiffany L. Cabán

So I appreciate you.

Tiffany L. Cabán

Thank you.

Tiffany L. Cabán

Yeah, go for it.

Member of the Public - JJ Cleo Mizrahi

Yeah, I just, it's always hard to like time consume with everything.

Member of the Public - JJ Cleo Mizrahi

But, you know, I'm thinking about also as someone who grew up in New York, who did not know about my rights and about accessing certain safe spaces, you know, about how, for example, growing up in the Orthodox Jewish community, there's misinformation.

Member of the Public - JJ Cleo Mizrahi

When I came out, my mother said to me, not long ago, she says, all you'll ever be is a prostitute.

Member of the Public - JJ Cleo Mizrahi

And my father said, all you'll ever be, no one will ever love you.

Member of the Public - JJ Cleo Mizrahi

And these are messages we're internalizing that they are taking from the media, right?

Member of the Public - JJ Cleo Mizrahi

And I had to make a really hard predicament over a decade ago where my mother said, either you comply to my rules despite paying the rent and able by law to, you know, not have to

Member of the Public - JJ Cleo Mizrahi

observe her faith, you know, because we have a different Jewish denomination.

Member of the Public - JJ Cleo Mizrahi

She said, either you have to take your hormones and you have to leave or you don't.

Member of the Public - JJ Cleo Mizrahi

And, you know, I was subjected to abuse for many years and never got help.

Member of the Public - JJ Cleo Mizrahi

And this is the reality for many people.

Member of the Public - JJ Cleo Mizrahi

And there's so many stories of people who, whether they leave a fundamentalist faith or whether they're not in a supportive

Member of the Public - JJ Cleo Mizrahi

environment, and what does that do to them long term about having internalized about who they are and feeling fearful that you're hated and that you're paranoid.

Member of the Public - JJ Cleo Mizrahi

And it's still even hard, I'll just end, with trans elders to remind you that not everyone's against you, but I will say that everyone in the community is on guard.

Member of the Public - JJ Cleo Mizrahi

And it breaks my heart to even go to a support group and see people terrified of just simply wanting to change other parts of their documentation and feel like we have to hide until the Trumpism is over.

Member of the Public - JJ Cleo Mizrahi

So thank you so much.

Member of the Public - Kristen Clifford

Thank you all.