Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Restler asks about average MWBE contract size disparity

New York City Council · Sep 23, 2026 · starts 0:49:51 · 1 min 52 sec

Restler notes the average MWBE contract was about $750,000 versus $3.65 million for white male-owned firms. Garner attributes the disparity to lack of access to capital, surety bonding, and right-sized contracting, and says the city is working to create prime opportunities.

Lincoln Restler

So I just want to kind of continue to harp on the issue of the value of MWBE contracts relative to non-MWBE contracts.

Lincoln Restler

So the data we looked at from FY25 was that the average MWBE contract was about $750,000.

Lincoln Restler

The average non-MW white male-owned firm, I should just say it that way, right?

Lincoln Restler

The average contract for a white male-owned firm was $3.65 million.

Lincoln Restler

Could you explain what you think accounts for this disparity?

Lincoln Restler

I mean, that's more than four times differential, average of a white male-owned firm versus a non-white male-owned firm.

Lincoln Restler

Why do you think we have such an extreme disparity there?

Michael J. Garner

Right.

Michael J. Garner

So, I mean, it is not unique to only the city of New York.

Michael J. Garner

I can tell you at the state.

Michael J. Garner

Agreed.

Michael J. Garner

75% of MWB contract awards are awarded at the sub-level as opposed to the prime level.

Michael J. Garner

When you factor in the lack of access to capital, when you factor in the lack of access to surety bonding, when you factor the lack of the right size contracting for MWBE firms, you will always see that.

Michael J. Garner

But we are working internally, certainly with...

Michael J. Garner

with our partners at SBS, access to capital programs, the bundling of contracts at the agencies, designing smaller packages,

Michael J. Garner

and having the ability to go out and recruit MWBEs and put them in the contracting critical path that they can bid as primes.

Michael J. Garner

Because when in a contract as a prime, as you know, you are in control of your own destiny.

Michael J. Garner

And so we are very focused on creating opportunities for our MWBE firms at the prime level.

Michael J. Garner

Working as a subcontractor, hey, listen, it's a good business for some, but let's not fool ourselves.

Michael J. Garner

We need to do a more effective job of creating prime opportunities for our MWBE firms.