Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Morano questions whether general population is clinically appropriate

New York City Council · Sep 23, 2026 · starts 0:48:22 · 2 min 43 sec

Council Member Frank Morano asks Otonichar whether housing someone with mental illness in general population means it is clinically best or simply the best available. Otonichar says patients are continuously assessed and that PACE waitlist currently includes 24 patients needing higher care.

Selvena N. Brooks-Powers

We're going to go to Councilmember Marano.

Frank Morano

Thank you, Chair.

Frank Morano

Thank you all for your testimony.

Frank Morano

I'd love to begin with Dr.

Frank Morano

Otonashar.

Frank Morano

You testified that most people with mental health needs are appropriately housed in general population.

Frank Morano

And I want to be very precise about the word appropriately.

Frank Morano

When CHS says someone is appropriately housed in general population, does that mean CHS believes general population is the clinically best placement?

Frank Morano

Or can it mean it's simply the best placement currently available?

Joseph Otonichar

So we continuously assess throughout an individual's incarceration what their clinical needs are, how closely they need to be monitored.

Joseph Otonichar

Similar to the community standard, patients who are able to function higher and less in distress are able to be brought to their appointment similar to the way you and I would go to an outpatient clinic.

Joseph Otonichar

For those individuals who are more vulnerable, who benefit from closer monitoring, who benefit from

Joseph Otonichar

greater support, we would transfer those patients onto a therapeutic housing unit until those needs are stabilized.

Joseph Otonichar

And we often will keep them there indefinitely.

Frank Morano

So specifically, among people with serious mental illness who are currently in general population, how many would be in a more therapeutic setting if every clinically appropriate bed were available today?

Joseph Otonichar

Can you rephrase your question?

Frank Morano

So among people with serious mental illness who are currently in general population,

Frank Morano

how many would be in a more therapeutic setting if every clinically appropriate bed were available today?

Joseph Otonichar

We consistently do assess the needs and assign patients to whatever level of care is appropriate.

Joseph Otonichar

Currently, all patients who require a particular level of care are transferred to that level of care.

Frank Morano

So what we have is sufficient.

Joseph Otonichar

Particularly understanding.

Joseph Otonichar

I think another way of thinking about it, there's currently 24 patients who are waiting placement on a PACE unit, so they do require a higher level of care.

Joseph Otonichar

We had an influx of hospital returns, and so those individuals are being closely monitored on MO, but they do require PACE.

Joseph Otonichar

But I do think it's a common misconception that anyone who has a serious mental illness requires a residential treatment level of care.

Joseph Otonichar

So GP is...

Joseph Otonichar

Clinically appropriate.