Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Remarks

Council Member Dinowitz responds to genocide claims and defends Israel

New York City Council · Sep 24, 2026 · starts 1:02:54 · 2 min 9 sec

Eric Dinowitz responds to earlier comments, disputing claims of genocide, arguing the term is used before and after military action, and defending Israel against what he calls demonizing language.

Amanda C. Farías

Thank you.

Amanda C. Farías

And our last speaker is Councilmember Dinowitz.

Eric Dinowitz

Thank you.

Eric Dinowitz

I just have to say, after hearing some of the comments about visitors to the country, however you feel about those individual visitors,

Eric Dinowitz

you know, this word that I keep hearing, this genocide, this claim of genocide, is a claim that was made

Eric Dinowitz

before Israel even started retaliating against Hamas after October 7th.

Eric Dinowitz

when they murdered and raped over a thousand people.

Eric Dinowitz

And it's just ridiculous to me that before the retaliation was claims of genocide, after

Eric Dinowitz

after a ceasefire, that same word is being used.

Eric Dinowitz

And the problem is, what does it do?

Eric Dinowitz

It obscures the actual issues that are going on there, the actual trauma and the actual destruction that is happening in the region.

Eric Dinowitz

You are unable, we are unable to have a real conversation and really address actual policy issues because of the demonizing language that existed before there was any military action and after there is a ceasefire

Eric Dinowitz

in place.

Eric Dinowitz

And the demonization causes real harm.

Eric Dinowitz

And it is very specific to one country.

Eric Dinowitz

And the reason we know this, the reason we say we should stop doing any aid to Israel, is because the very same people saying that, out of one side of their mouth,

Eric Dinowitz

out of the other side say we should never sanction any country.

Eric Dinowitz

We should never boycott from any country because that will only serve to hurt the citizens and the people who live in that country.

Eric Dinowitz

But there is a special exception made for Israel and it is especially okay apparently to use this

Eric Dinowitz

demonizing language without evidence before the war begins and after the ceasefire is in place.

Eric Dinowitz

Thank you, Majority Leader.