Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Alexa Aviles moves to Zoom panel; Antonio Rosario testifies

New York City Council · Sep 28, 2026 · starts 5:01:06 · 3 min 56 sec

Council Member Aviles moves to a Zoom panel. Antonio Rosario, a proud Boricua with family in Cabo Rojo, testifies in support of Resolution 494. He describes the water and infrastructure challenges facing the island.

Alexa Avilés

Gracias, gracias.

Alexa Avilés

Next we're going to move to a Zoom panel.

Alexa Avilés

We're going to have Antonio Rosario.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

You may begin.

Alexa Avilés

We're going to resume in person.

Alexa Avilés

We are going to give opportunity for Antonio Rosario, Calvin, and Freddie.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

Gracias, Alexa.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

Can everybody hear me?

Alexa Avilés

Yes, we can hear you.

Alexa Avilés

Please start.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

My name is Antonio Rosario.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

I'm a proud 32-year teenster, a worker, a father, and proud Boricua.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

And today, I'm speaking not just as someone who cares about Puerto Rico, but someone who has family that comes from Cabo Rojo.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

My mother was born in Cabo Rojo.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

I spent my summers there as a kid.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

Cabo Rojo is in some distant place on a map to me.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

It is a part of who I am.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

And now I bring my own children there.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

We visit our families that are down there in Cabo Rojo.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

I used to run around La Santa Rita Residencial as a kid.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

We call them caserios.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

We visit our family.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

We walk the land.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

We see the beauty of the island.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

And we also see the reality that the people living there face every day.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

I've been there when the water has been shut off.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

I've been there when the electricity has gone out.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

I've seen firsthand.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

What those things mean for our families who live there.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

So when I hear about a massive development that could require more than 1.25 million, excuse my language, sorry, gallons of water every day, I don't hear the number.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

The statistic, I think about my familia, I think about the people who already live there, and I have to ask, how can we talk about building luxury resorts and golf courses and private

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

residences when the people who already call Cabo a home are still dealing with basic infrastructure challenges?

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

That's why I'm here today to support Resolution 5494.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

The New York City Council's resolution recognizes Project Exacia for what it is, a proposed $2 billion luxury development covering more than 2,000 acres with hundreds of hotels, more than 1,000 residences, golf courses, private airport, and luxury amenities.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

The resolution also raises concerns about water, wetlands, endangered species, archaeological sites, public beaches, and the impact of the surrounding communities.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

And these concerns aren't coming only from the people standing outside with protest signs.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

The Puerto Rican Senate has been investigating the project.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

In recent hearings, government agencies have raised serious questions about infrastructure and water capacity.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

The Puerto Rico Aqueducts and Sewer Authority has stated that existing Potencias filtration plant does not have the design capacity to supply the project and stimulate demand without additional infrastructure improvements.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

That matters to me because I've seen the consequences of the inadequate water structure.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

And I want the children of Puerto Rico and the working families are told to conserve water while luxury developments are guaranteed with resources they need.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

Water is not a luxury.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

Electricity is not a luxury.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

Housing is not a luxury.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

A healthy environment is not a luxury.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

These are things that people deserve.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

These are human rights.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

brings me to Resolution 2728.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

These resolutions speak a larger question on who determines Puerto Rico's future.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

Resolution 27 calls for the action against financial practices that allow outside financial interests to profit from Puerto Rico's debt crisis, while Resolution 28 calls on Congress to establish a date certain for ending the financial oversight and management board.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

For me, these issues are connected.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

Because whether we're talking about debt, development, land, water, and natural resources, we have to ask, who's Puerto Rico developed for?

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

Is it being developed for the people who live there?

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

Is it for the families who have their generations?

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

For our children?

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

Being developed for ground one outside investors and extract the island, Puerto Rico cannot simply be treated as an investment opportunity.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

Viva Puerto Rico, viva Puerto Rico libre.

Member of the Public - Antonio Rosario

Esencia Canova, sorry.