Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Council Member Thomas-Henry asks about capital funding lead times; library directors respond

New York City Council · Sep 28, 2026 · starts 2:21:25 · 5 min 4 sec

Council Member Shanel Thomas-Henry asks about capital funding lead times for library projects. Julie Golia, Roberta Pineda, Natiba Guy-Clement, Joy Bivens, and Julie Golia discuss the complexities of the capital process and the need for reform.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

Thank you, Chair.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

I want to piggyback off one of your finance questions.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

I can remember starting a couple of months ago and speaking to QL, Queens Public Library leadership, and we were talking about capital.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

They had all these amazing capital projects to be funded and said,

Shanel Thomas-Henry

This is what we need.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

We're going to tell you now it won't start for seven years.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

I only have an eight year term.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

So my question to you all is, when you're trying to expand your collections, when you're trying to make improvements, how does, one, I know what the lead time for Queens is.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

Is it the same lead time across the city?

Shanel Thomas-Henry

And how do you plan for that, prepare for that, and how can we do better by you in the city to expedite the process?

Member of the Public - Julie Golia

Can you clarify, do you mean in terms of the collecting that we're doing or in terms of broader?

Shanel Thomas-Henry

Capital funding.

Member of the Public - Julie Golia

Broader capital funding.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

Broader capital funding.

Member of the Public - Roberta Pineda

I will say that one of the challenging parts of this job is that we are in the business of forever.

Member of the Public - Roberta Pineda

We are collecting this material and we are safeguarding it.

Member of the Public - Roberta Pineda

This is not our material, we're just holding it.

Member of the Public - Roberta Pineda

And so, as we were even mentioning before with all these climate concerns, it becomes really important to have good capital infrastructure, right?

Member of the Public - Roberta Pineda

And so,

Member of the Public - Roberta Pineda

A lot of that is very complicated, as you mentioned.

Member of the Public - Roberta Pineda

You know, you're looking at some money to fix a roof or something, and then you understand that that's going to take many years.

Member of the Public - Roberta Pineda

What do you do until then?

Member of the Public - Roberta Pineda

So I think that, to answer your question, yes, if the systems were a little bit less complicated and we could get these important capital upgrades

Member of the Public - Roberta Pineda

done faster, I think this would actually make all our collections safer.

Member of the Public - Natiba Guy-Clement

It's the same process for us at BPL as well.

Member of the Public - Natiba Guy-Clement

Of course, we try to expedite things as much as we can.

Member of the Public - Natiba Guy-Clement

I think we also have the added challenge at CBH of being a landmark building with a landmark interior library, which, beautiful to look at, but, you know, it...

Member of the Public - Natiba Guy-Clement

The building was built in 1881, and there's a lot more stuff.

Member of the Public - Natiba Guy-Clement

So we really try to think creatively in terms of how we manage collection storage.

Member of the Public - Natiba Guy-Clement

We do off-site storage.

Member of the Public - Natiba Guy-Clement

We do try to limit the amount of time it takes to get materials to our researchers.

Member of the Public - Natiba Guy-Clement

But of course, yeah, any funding to help that, of course, we'll all appreciate it.

Member of the Public - Joy Bivens

You're looking at me, so I think I'm supposed to answer the question.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

Because you have such a beautiful space here.

Member of the Public - Joy Bivens

Yes, it is beautiful.

Member of the Public - Joy Bivens

And we are about to embark on a facade project to replace all of the windows for this particular building.

Member of the Public - Joy Bivens

And it has...

Member of the Public - Joy Bivens

Taken many, many years to get to the point of starting.

Member of the Public - Joy Bivens

And, you know, there's contractors, there's contracts, there are issues around, this is not the landmark building, but we do have a landmark building.

Member of the Public - Joy Bivens

So I'm not sure, I think the funding is one thing, then there's the kind of machinations and process of actually

Member of the Public - Joy Bivens

either city or state contracts.

Member of the Public - Joy Bivens

So I'm not sure how to answer that question.

Member of the Public - Joy Bivens

It has taken many years, really.

Member of the Public - Julie Golia

I think we are so grateful for the council's support, and I think the council knows that we have worked

Member of the Public - Julie Golia

for a while on the challenges around the process.

Member of the Public - Julie Golia

I think the challenges very much have to do with the process.

Member of the Public - Julie Golia

And I think as Roberta says, in the meantime, we are preserving, in the case of the law,

Member of the Public - Julie Golia

55 million collection items that we are on the hook for maintaining forever.

Member of the Public - Julie Golia

So I think we are really eager to work with you and support any ways to reform the complexities of the process.

Member of the Public - Julie Golia

We all get it.

Member of the Public - Julie Golia

We work at bureaucratic places as well, so we get it.

Member of the Public - Julie Golia

But this would...

Member of the Public - Julie Golia

Greatly help us be better and more responsible stewards to preserving these collections for future children, generations of the people that we are doing this for.

Member of the Public - Julie Golia

And in the meantime, we try to work around the capital process in any way that we can, which is not an ideal situation.

Member of the Public - Julie Golia

So we really look forward to more conversations on how we can refine that process.