Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Ramon Cruz testifies on resolutions

New York City Council · Sep 28, 2026 · starts 4:39:40 · 2 min 36 sec

Ramon Cruz, external affairs coordinator for Movimiento Victoria Ciudadana, testifies in support of the four resolutions. He asks who decides how Puerto Rico's resources are used and who benefits from those decisions.

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

Okay, good afternoon.

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

My name is Ramon Cruz, and I'm the External Affairs Coordinator for the Movimiento Victoria Ciudadana, a movement committed to a progressive and anti-colonial vision for Puerto Rico and to building a more transparent, equitable, and socially responsible government.

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

Today I want to address you in favor of your four resolutions, the Fiscal Control Board, Act 22, and Essencia Project.

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

These are all connected by one fundamental question.

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

Who decides how Puerto Rico's resources are used?

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

Who benefits from those decisions?

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

And who ultimately bears the costs?

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

Ten years after Promesa, Victoria Ciudadana believes the Fiscal Control Board must go.

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

Puerto Rico cannot speak of true democracy while fundamental decisions over our public resources remain subject to an entity imposed upon rather than elected by the Puerto Rican people.

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

For years, Puerto Ricans have been told that fiscal responsibility requires sacrifice.

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

But fiscal responsibility cannot mean austerity for workers and communities while tax incentives, government contracts, and benefits to powerful economic interests escape the same scrutiny.

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

That principle applies to Act 22.

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

We support investment and we welcome people who want to make Puerto Rico their home.

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

But when government provides extraordinary tax advantage,

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

It must demonstrate the public benefits with data on jobs, wages, revenues, and economic returns.

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

And we must examine also the effects of housing and displacement when families earning local wages compete in an increasingly unaffordable market.

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

So this is not what Act 22 has left us.

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

And Act 22 doesn't help Puerto Ricans.

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

The same principles applies to Essencia.

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

We're not against development, but recent Puerto Rican Senate hearings have raised serious questions about water, infrastructure, environmental impacts, and costs to surrounding community.

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

And development must demonstrate a genuine public benefit.

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

But this is not what Essencia does.

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

Time expired.

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

So far, what these three issues point out is that Puerto Rico is for the wealthy that have no interest in the development of our people.

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

That is why we condemn all of this and support your resolution.

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

Ultimately, our standards should be simple.

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

Does our economic model allow the people who work in Puerto Rico to afford a home, raise their families, and build their future there?

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

So Puerto Rico's resources must serve Puerto Rico's people.

Member of the Public - Ramon Cruz

Thank you.