Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Chair Abreu asks what percentage of collisions involve illegal devices

New York City Council · Sep 30, 2026 · starts 1:36:32 · 1 min 35 sec

Abreu asks what percentage of collisions involve illegal devices, and Chief Obey says NYPD does not break down data by legal vs. non-street legal.

Shaun Abreu

Of collisions involving motorized micromobility devices, what percentage involve illegal devices?

Shaun Abreu

I don't know if PD has this information.

Chief Obey

So we track very generally.

Chief Obey

I think the difficulty, I think, is one of the reasons why we're here today.

Chief Obey

We don't break down.

Chief Obey

The data and collisions by legal or non-street legal.

Chief Obey

It's just e-bike, stand-up scooter, that type of thing, but we don't do legal versus non-street legal.

Shaun Abreu

Does the admin have a plan to begin collecting that data?

Shaun Abreu

I think having that information, again, is very important.

Unidentified speaker

Totally understood, though I will say, and I think this will be coming up over the course of the hearing, right, part of the challenge is that

Unidentified speaker

sometimes, particularly with e-bikes, being able to tell on its face whether it's a street legal or street illegal device can be very difficult to determine.

Unidentified speaker

Now, when you have a fatality and you have sort of an in-depth CIS investigation, we're going to be able to determine that.

Unidentified speaker

But to the extent, you know, talking about an accident, no fatality, no serious injury, and that's a serious matter.

Unidentified speaker

I'm not making light of any accident.

Unidentified speaker

But I would say different type of investigation is going to go into that.

Unidentified speaker

To the extent in every case.

Unidentified speaker

We would have to determine whether a particular e-bike is street legal or street legal on its face.

Unidentified speaker

That's a complicated matter.

Unidentified speaker

I'm not saying it's impossible, but that is very challenging.