Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Council Member Wilson asks DOT about sidewalk detection technology research

New York City Council · Sep 30, 2026 · starts 3:25:15 · 1 min 59 sec

Carl Wilson asks what research informed DOT's determination that sidewalk detection technology is ineffective, and DOT says it is based on observation and industry conversations.

Carl Wilson

Thank you, Chair.

Carl Wilson

Hi, Commissioner.

Carl Wilson

In your testimony, you said that the sidewalk detection technology is ineffective or doesn't work very well.

Carl Wilson

I was wondering if you could tell me a little bit about what research informed that decision or that determination.

Unidentified speaker

Sure.

Unidentified speaker

So I'll need to check with the team on specifics of the research we did, but I know that we're constantly monitoring what's out there and tracking the industry and seeing what's available.

Unidentified speaker

I think it's based on observation and awareness of what products are out there.

Unidentified speaker

And we're involved with various industry groups where we trade information and things like that.

Unidentified speaker

We're always trying to stay at the forefront.

Unidentified speaker

We've had conversations with some of the operators as well and some peer cities.

Unidentified speaker

So, I mean, at a high level, that's sort of what it's based on.

Unidentified speaker

I mean, I would want to reiterate that we're certainly strongly in support of the goal.

Unidentified speaker

So it's really just about trying to identify the specific tools that can get us there.

Carl Wilson

Just in conversations like that I've had with folks in the industry, they tell us that technology does exist and that it can work.

Carl Wilson

So, like, how often is that?

Carl Wilson

reviewed?

Carl Wilson

How often are you checking?

Carl Wilson

You said all the time, but what does that really mean?

Unidentified speaker

I'm not sure I can quantify it, but we have a pretty large team devoted to Vision Zero policy research, analysis.

Unidentified speaker

They're involved with different groups.

Unidentified speaker

We talk to the manufacturers.

Unidentified speaker

As you can imagine, the manufacturers come to us a lot.

Unidentified speaker

Everybody has a product.

Unidentified speaker

Everybody says their product can do everything and is great.

Unidentified speaker

We have to try to unpack it a bit.

Unidentified speaker

So, I mean, we're hopeful that the technology can get there, but at this moment, we're not confident.