Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Public Advocate Williams asks about speed enforcement technology

New York City Council · Sep 30, 2026 · starts 3:12:22 · 2 min 28 sec

Williams asks how the city determines when e-bikes are speeding, and NYPD explains they use LIDAR and officer experience, but cannot assess maximum speed of a device.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

I did have one question as I end this, and this may have been answered where I was going, but I know there is an issue that we don't have the technology to know when folks are speeding on mopeds and bicycles.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

So how do we determine that when we want to enforce

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

speeding regulations.

Unidentified speaker

So I think we're referring to is the dynamometer issue we were talking about earlier.

Unidentified speaker

To be clear, the challenge is being able to determine what the maximum speed is of, let's say, an e-bike.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

I want to be clear about the question.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

So if I think someone is

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

speeding on a, well a moped, many of them shouldn't be on it, but like an electric bike that's going too fast, how do we know that if it's going too fast?

Oswald J. Feliz

I believe you don't know.

Unidentified speaker

Okay, so on the speed end, how we currently enforce speeding, there's two ways.

Unidentified speaker

First, we have a device called LIDAR, that's L-I-D-A-R.

Unidentified speaker

I apologize, I don't, it's acronym, I don't have the whole,

Unidentified speaker

That is used just like the high, it's similar to what the highway officers use on the highway.

Unidentified speaker

It's pointed towards the device itself and it's able to record speed.

Unidentified speaker

The other way is that officer has to tickle it, essentially saying,

Unidentified speaker

Based on my own professional experience, I can determine that this vehicle, this particular device was going at a certain speed because near misses.

Unidentified speaker

You know, we had pedestrians jump out of the way, that type of thing, or I was in my...

Unidentified speaker

Just to be clear, right, so you have situations where there's reckless driving.

Unidentified speaker

The person may well, in fact, be going way over the speed limit.

Unidentified speaker

We may not be able to capture that in terms of a number, but to the extent they're operating their device, again, this is true for anyone, right?

Unidentified speaker

This would be true for a driver of a four-wheeled vehicle, traditional bicycle, micromobility device, whatever it may be.

Unidentified speaker

If someone is driving recklessly, irrespective of the speed, right, they're subject to a summons.

Unidentified speaker

And then separately, there are circumstances where we have the technology to assess the speed at which a device...

Unidentified speaker

Actually is operating.

Unidentified speaker

What we cannot do, we do not have technology to

Unidentified speaker

to assess what is the maximum speed of a particular device.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

Okay, thank you, Mr.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

Chair.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

Just for clarity, there is a device now that you can use, and then you use the experience of officers to see if someone is speeding.

Unidentified speaker

That is correct.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

Thank you.