Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Renee Baruch testifies about being run over by an e-bike

New York City Council · Sep 30, 2026 · starts 4:22:44 · 2 min 6 sec

Renee Baruch describes being hospitalized for a week after being run over by an e-bike in 2023, and calls for passage of Priscilla's Law for accountability.

Member of the Public - Renee Baruch

My name is Renee Baruch, and although she's not present, I would thank the speaker for this opportunity to be heard.

Member of the Public - Renee Baruch

In May 2023, I was run over by an e-bike.

Member of the Public - Renee Baruch

This was the result.

Member of the Public - Renee Baruch

The photograph you see was taken after surgery was performed on, which closed several cuts on my face.

Member of the Public - Renee Baruch

The fractures had to heal on their own.

Member of the Public - Renee Baruch

I was hospitalized for a total of a week, and I later had surgery to fix the damage to my cervical spine.

Member of the Public - Renee Baruch

I was told that it was a delivery worker, but of course I don't know the identity, and I only regained consciousness once I was in the ambulance.

Member of the Public - Renee Baruch

We have no means of identifying the driver of any motorized bike.

Member of the Public - Renee Baruch

I was recently in Europe with a huge bicycle culture where there was no infrastructure, just a painted line.

Member of the Public - Renee Baruch

And there were bike racks at all the railroad stations and outside of buildings.

Member of the Public - Renee Baruch

But they all stopped for red lights and stop signs, and they obeyed the traffic rules.

Member of the Public - Renee Baruch

Even as a casual observer, you know that it is not safe to cross a New York City street if you're in the crosswalk, if you have a green light.

Member of the Public - Renee Baruch

Unless you first look both ways to make sure that something isn't still coming at you.

Member of the Public - Renee Baruch

Thank God my vision remains intact.

Member of the Public - Renee Baruch

No enforcement of any traffic laws is taking place, and you must pass Priscilla's Law Intro 802 as soon as possible.

Unidentified speaker

Thank you for your testimony.