Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Madeline Garcia-Bigelow testifies for Domestic Violence Project

New York City Council · Sep 30, 2026 · starts 2:04:44 · 3 min 44 sec

Garcia-Bigelow, a 33-year advocate, lists recent domestic violence homicides and criticizes the mayor's silence. She says NGBV was built with survivors and providers, warns consolidation risks deprioritizing specialized work, and asks for survivor-led policymaking and a real seat at the table.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

Good afternoon, Chair Farias and members of the committee.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

Thank you so much for holding this hearing.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

My name is Madeline Garcia-Bigelow.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

I'm the founder and managing director of the Domestic Violence Project housed at the Urban Justice Center.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

I have worked on behalf of survivors for 33 years as a DV prosecutor in the Bronx, a civil attorney, and now as a founder.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

In the eight months of this administration, at least six high-profile domestic violence homicides have taken place in New York City.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

LaVey Williams, Angelique Apostle, Erica Caldwell, Yesenia Hall, Maria Ines Granda,

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

and Dana Foley.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

And yet, we have not heard the mayor condemn domestic violence clearly and unequivocally, even after each of these homicides.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

New York City has spent more than a quarter century building a dedicated survivor-centered system.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

In 2001, through City Charter, the Mayor's Office to Combat Domestic Violence was created.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

And then in 2018, the mission was expanded and it was renamed NGBV.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

But these aren't simply titles.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

They embody and symbolize years of advocacy, of conversation, and education led by survivors and providers.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

It was built with survivors and providers.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

And even though it collaborates with...

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

really closely with law enforcement in the courts, it is decidedly distinct from that.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

Executive Order 15 folded that work into the Office of Community Safety.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

Consolidation in and of itself is not a disqualifier, but DV is not interchangeable with gun violence interruption or general mental health response.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

Survivors have distinct safety planning needs.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

They have distinct confidentiality protections and a justified wariness of anything that looks like general public safety.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

During July's quarterly crime stats press conference, Commissioner Tisch noted a 6% reduction in major crimes, but pointed out the felony assaults remained flat, with DV accounting for 42% of those assaults.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

Since the executive order, providers and survivors have not been included in any real conversation about what comes next.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

So when restructuring happens in silence, survivors cannot tell whether a service still exists, advocates can't make accurate referrals, and decades of expertise risk being deprioritized.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

And the need is growing.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

Since January, in the eight months of this administration, my team of 23 has opened 2,069 new cases.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

Our warm line has answered 1,267 calls, more than all the calls received in 2025.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

Over 65% of our clients are immigrants, and most of them are undocumented.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

In the most recent issue of City and State asked about the DSA's strong showing in the June primaries, the mayor said his most important goal is delivering for New Yorkers,

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

that he is less interested in narrowing who he works with than in expanding who can sit across the table from.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

So we take him at his word.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

Mayor Mandani, invite us to the table.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

We ask this council to use its oversight authority to secure a commitment to a survivor-centered, survivor-led policy-making process with an actual, real seat at the table for the survivors and the providers.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

Again, thank you for holding this hearing.