Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Madeline Garcia-Bigelow warns against narrowing funding and cites DOVE flexibility

New York City Council · Sep 30, 2026 · starts 2:17:58 · 2 min 44 sec

Garcia-Bigelow says diverse survivor needs should not be forced into one bucket or infighting over rigid deliverables. She praises DOVE and COVID-era flexible funding and criticizes OCS for not separating domestic violence as it did mental health.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

Literally just a couple of seconds.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

I think it's been about 15 people that have spoken.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

And when I was thinking through, what is it that we're missing?

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

I think we'll be missing a lot more if OCS continues the way that it's been discussed about today through the commissioner.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

Because these are all needs that are all diverse and making it all one thing or another or just really focusing on, but we've given $15.7 million.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

The biggest amount since 2018.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

That's terrific.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

Liz Roberts saying the pie needs to be expanded.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

Yes, all of it is important.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

So that survivors can elect to move forward and have the privilege to decide who's going to help us, how do we want to be helped, and if you're not helping me, I can elect to go somewhere else.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

But the more we narrow things and make it where we're actually almost infighting for a bucket of money that the way

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

it is defined is through deliverables that don't really have anything to do with the work that's being done or a comprehension of the complexity of it.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

I will say that one of the two, in my experience, two buckets of funding that have been exceptionally helpful have been DOVE

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

because it does allow you to pivot in ways that other grants simply don't allow.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

Like you have to beg.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

to can I please, I use this money instead of MetroCards for this, and the flexible funding that came as a result of COVID that has been continued statewide.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

And I think that

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

That's what we need.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

We need a belief in what survivors are saying is their need, and that need isn't stagnant.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

Privilege is, in many respects, the ability to choose what you want and not lose your foothold.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

And I think that this administration, although I hope that they step up,

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

They've made it real clear for eight months.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

That it's all right, we got this.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

I mean, we got it.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

It's under Office of Community Safety.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

They even recognize that mental health should be a separate division within Office of Community Safety, but not DV.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

With these stories, not DV.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

I said a few seconds.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

I sometimes am not truthful.

Member of the Public - Madeline Garcia Bigelow

Sorry.