Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Oren Hemovitis testifies for Legal Aid Society on NGBV independence

New York City Council · Sep 30, 2026 · starts 2:35:04 · 4 min

A Legal Aid staff attorney in the Family Law Domestic Violence Unit says Legal Aid urges keeping NGBV as its own office. He cites City Charter Section 19 classifying domestic violence as a public health issue and says added bureaucracy lessens NGBV's authority and coordination.

Member of the Public

That's okay.

Amanda C. Farías

You can begin when ready.

Member of the Public

Okay.

Member of the Public

Good afternoon.

Member of the Public

Thank you to Chair Farias and the committee for the opportunity to speak.

Member of the Public

I'm speaking today on behalf of the Legal Aid Society.

Member of the Public

The Legal Aid Society was founded here in New York City in 1876.

Member of the Public

We are the oldest and largest provider of legal services in the United States.

Member of the Public

We handle some 300,000 cases and legal matters per year for low-income New Yorkers with civil, criminal, and juvenile rights problems.

Member of the Public

I have been a staff attorney in our Family Law Domestic Violence Unit in our civil practice since 2019.

Member of the Public

The Family DV Unit represents survivors of domestic violence in both Supreme and Family Court.

Member of the Public

My fellow attorneys and I provide full representation to help survivors assert their rights to custody of their children, to child support and maintenance, to equitable distribution of property, and their right to be safe and free from harm.

Member of the Public

We urge the Mamdani administration to keep NGBV operating as its own office.

Member of the Public

NGBV has been operating for 25 years and has been successful.

Member of the Public

We strongly believe that independence was a key to that success and that making the office part of OCS will detract from its independence and by extension its mission.

Member of the Public

OCS seeks to address community violence with a community-centered model based in restoration and community

Member of the Public

accountability.

Member of the Public

This goal is commendable and needed, but domestic violence is not a community safety issue.

Member of the Public

The New York City Charter itself, Section 19, the section which established NGBV in the first place, classifies domestic violence as a public health issue, not a community safety issue.

Member of the Public

NGBV was created and structured with the clear goal of making a focused and streamlined effort to address domestic violence coordinated across city agencies.

Member of the Public

The director was appointed by and answered directly to the mayor to give NGBV access to quick decision-making and high authority when needed to facilitate intensive cross-disciplinary focus.

Member of the Public

Which Section 19 of the City Charter envisioned.

Member of the Public

Every layer of bureaucracy which is added between NGBV and the mayor lessens the perceived authority of the office and accordingly the ability of NGBV to work across agency lines.

Member of the Public

I can personally attest to the success of NGBV.

Member of the Public

I've been very familiar with that office through the Family Justice Center.

Member of the Public

Their dedicated and hardworking staff offer survivors of DV a wide range of counseling and services, including legal services.

Member of the Public

And they send people to me to screen to discuss their cases and give legal advice.

Member of the Public

They help other legal service providers also coordinate with agencies to better represent their clients.

Member of the Public

On my own cases, I have seen the ease with which

Member of the Public

Agencies can communicate when facilitated by the Family Justice Center.

Member of the Public

center, and when they coordinate, how they can help provide a systemic answer to a devastating problem.

Member of the Public

And I'm concerned about anything which could take away that coordination and communication.

Member of the Public

Efforts to streamline the city government and reduce bureaucracy are needed.

Member of the Public

But NGBV represents just such an effort, a successful and long-running one.

Member of the Public

NGBV already had access to resources and was empowered by the Charter to coordinate with other agencies, and I have personally seen that coordination in action to good effect.

Member of the Public

Taking away NGBV's independence sends the wrong signal to survivors and those who advocate for survivors.

Member of the Public

The people of New York City voted to amend the city charter to establish NGBV in 2001 so that the city could have an office that would comprehensively address issues of domestic violence.

Member of the Public

The administration should listen to that mandate and keep NGBV independent from OCS and let it continue succeeding in its mission.

Member of the Public

Thank you for your time.

Amanda C. Farías

Thank you so much for providing testimony today.