Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Williams questions officials on workforce bills and deepfake legislation

New York City Council · Oct 5, 2026 · starts 7:46:40 · 4 min 42 sec

Williams asks about state workforce legislation and about US deepfake law and international cooperation. Bores mentions Senator Gonzalez's workforce bill and pending deepfake and chatbot bills; Vanel describes recent deepfake laws and a new artist-impersonation issue; Asato explains gendered deepfake harms and consent-based approaches.

Nantasha M. Williams

Just two more quick questions.

Nantasha M. Williams

I passed a bill and the chair has a bill on AI's impact on the municipal workforce.

Nantasha M. Williams

Just wondering if there was any traction on that for the state's workforce.

Nantasha M. Williams

And then just a question for the member of parliament.

Nantasha M. Williams

My bill that we're hearing today is to address unauthorized use of deepfakes.

Nantasha M. Williams

So in addition to the privacy.

Nantasha M. Williams

laws and Britain just wanted to know if you all have specific legislation around deep fakes.

Nantasha M. Williams

And how you envision the cooperation with the international community, because you mentioned that.

Nantasha M. Williams

And what does that look like for you?

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

Thank you so much for your question.

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

We know that female elected representatives are 33 times more likely to be targeted by sexual deepfakes than men.

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

The whole issue around sexualized deepfakes is deeply gendered, and I think it's very important that we acknowledge that.

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

Because what it does is it drives women from the public space.

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

We know that women are less likely to talk about politics online than men are.

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

And that is because they become a target as soon as they raise their heads in this place, which is not social.

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

That is why taking action on this is so important and to be commended in terms of looking at this.

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

But when we're looking at these deep fakes, it needs to be for all of our citizens because it's not just about protecting those of us who have the honour of being elected.

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

It is about co-workers who may be targeted because

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

they didn't smile at the right time or your last date who wouldn't go on a second date with you or teachers who are being targeted by their male students.

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

All of these people need protection.

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

That's why in the UK we have taken steps to make sure that there is the criminalization of the creation of non-consensual sexual deepfakes.

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

But my view is that we need to go further than just the sexualized deepfakes because any act could be harmful to women.

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

The removal of a woman's hijab.

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

Through AI could put that woman in harm's way, but there's nothing sexualized about it.

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

And so we have to look at this as an issue, as I said, of consent.

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

And that is where data and privacy is so, so important.

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

And that's where I think there could be international agreement.

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

We can see, as you said, that things are moving forward within the EU space.

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

Really, though, what we need is for tech companies to be safe by design.

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

And every single country has those rules.

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

We should be looking at product regulation just as we do in the offline sphere.

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

At the end of the day, we have cars that have seatbelts and they have airbags.

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

And that's because we expect them to be safe by design.

Member of the Public - Sarah Sackman

It is not too much to expect that of the tech products that we use today.

Member of the Public - Alex Bores

On the question about the state workforce, I wish Senator Gonzalez could have heard that because she wrote the Loading Act, which helps to protect the state workforce.

Member of the Public - Alex Bores

And I think there's an update to it pending before the governor, which leads me to you asking about deep fakes as well.

Member of the Public - Alex Bores

There's a bill from Senator Granardis and I pending before the governor on that.

Member of the Public - Alex Bores

Senator Gonzalez also mentioned chatbots to protect kids.

Member of the Public - Alex Bores

There's a bill pending before the governor.

Member of the Public - Alex Bores

So I should have also added on ways you can help out is we are really happy to be here and advocate for the legislation you are putting forward and invite you, if you agree with some that's pending before the governor, to be a partner in pushing that as well.

Member of the Public - Clyde Vanel

Yeah, we have a number of deepfake bills, and we passed actually a number of, a couple of my bills became law with respect to deepfakes, with respect to elections.

Member of the Public - Clyde Vanel

One of the new bills that just came out was just very recently, I discovered an artist that I fell in love with on Apple Music, and I downloaded all her music.

Member of the Public - Clyde Vanel

I've been listening to her music for a while.

Member of the Public - Clyde Vanel

I actually went to go look for her a couple of days ago to follow her to go to a concert or something like that, found out.

Member of the Public - Clyde Vanel

It's not a person.

Member of the Public - Clyde Vanel

So there's no law, there's no regulation at all for these platforms to tell you whether or not you're listening to a real person or not.

Member of the Public - Clyde Vanel

Right?

Member of the Public - Clyde Vanel

So, you know, the bill, so one of the things that we have to do is figure out what that looks like moving forward.

Member of the Public - Clyde Vanel

So we're going to need your help on that.

Member of the Public - Clyde Vanel

That's something that we're going to really need your help on.

Nantasha M. Williams

Yeah, ask them specifically a question about it.

Nantasha M. Williams

And it was very fluffy.

Nantasha M. Williams

But I literally asked a question about that to the companies.

Nantasha M. Williams

Thank you all.

Nantasha M. Williams

Thank you.