Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Restler and Anderson discuss community composting funding and drop-off vs smart bins

New York City Council · Oct 15, 2026 · starts 1:06:39 · 2 min 31 sec

Restler and Anderson discuss the value of community compost drop-offs with dedicated composters. Anderson says community composting baseline funds were eliminated in 2023 and that drop-offs serve a different purpose than smart bins; Restler says he will continue pushing for tailored compost receptacles.

Gregory Anderson

If I can continue going, because I know his clock has run out.

Gregory Anderson

Okay, no one's saying no.

Gregory Anderson

On the drop-off side, I think the kinds of drop-offs that you're talking about are very different than the organic waste receptacles that the bill calls for.

Gregory Anderson

Those are drop-offs where you have a dedicated community composter standing next to the bin, helping people

Gregory Anderson

feel good about what they're doing and helping people understand that it's going to be turned into compost at a local community garden or at a community composting facility and go back to

Gregory Anderson

their local parks and gardens and whatever.

Gregory Anderson

And I think that's all great stuff.

Gregory Anderson

And I agree with you.

Gregory Anderson

When the community composting baseline funds were eliminated from the budget in November 2023, that was a massive, massive.

Gregory Anderson

Change to the way that we approach composting in New York City.

Gregory Anderson

And I have said before, I would love to have those baseline funds back in the budget so that we don't have to have this ongoing sort of tit for tat on whether composting is getting funded every year.

Gregory Anderson

I don't think that the people who are showing up at the green markets looking to have that interaction with the community composter and have that sort of

Gregory Anderson

you know, local sort of circular economy for their compost would necessarily

Gregory Anderson

the same way about using an organic waste receptacle like a smart bin that is collected by sanitation, goes to one of our industrial scale processing facilities, either a compost facility or anaerobic digestion.

Gregory Anderson

So I don't think it's all the same.

Lincoln Restler

I think you've made all very good points.

Lincoln Restler

And I think that

Lincoln Restler

I still feel that in super high-trafficked areas, in big parks like McCarran Park or Borough Hall, having a compost receptacle, having one of these compost smart bins still has value.

Lincoln Restler

So I'd love to continue the conversation if there's a much more tailored approach that you think could make sense.

Lincoln Restler

It doesn't sound like you think it does, but I will push you anyway.

Lincoln Restler

And I will say lastly, I also take credit for converting my wife into a compost enthusiast as well.

Gregory Anderson

I'm sure our wives will be thrilled that we're discussing them here.

Justin E. Sanchez

I was just going to say blessings to both of your wives.

Justin E. Sanchez

On behalf of the city of New York, thank you.