Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Remarks

Menin calls SpaceX AI testimony unsatisfactory and not credible

New York City Council · Oct 16, 2026 · starts 1:54:53 · 2 min 4 sec

Speaker Menin says SpaceX AI's answers were wholly unsatisfactory, citing Devin Kim's whistleblower testimony about his firing, the company's tasteful nudes standard, and the hyper-sexualized images of herself and thousands of women and children that Grok can generate within seconds; she thanks Kim for his bravery.

Julie Menin

Okay, thank you so much, Chair De La Rosa.

Julie Menin

I really want to say that the answers that we heard from SpaceX AI today were wholly and completely unsatisfactory.

Julie Menin

The idea that the basically company line about constant focus on safety was really belied by several things.

Julie Menin

First of all, the fact that the very compelling whistleblower testimony we heard from Devin Kim, whose testimony we were able to secure early this morning, and we appreciate him being here and his forthrightness.

Julie Menin

But the idea that SpaceX AI could not comment or couldn't about anything around his termination was extremely troubling at best.

Julie Menin

Secondly,

Julie Menin

As we discussed, we know that for

Julie Menin

for thousands and thousands of women and children who have had hyper-sexualized images of them posted online repeatedly.

Julie Menin

And then hearing from Mr.

Julie Menin

Kim, who was one of SpaceX's first employees, that the company thought that

Julie Menin

tasteful nudes were appropriate is really shocking, offensive, and wholly and completely unacceptable.

Julie Menin

And the fact that within seconds I could pull up a hyper-sexualized image of myself, numerous images, and in fact not only could we find them,

Julie Menin

Rock even had a way where you could make them more sexualized.

Julie Menin

You can make it, sort of pump it up even more and more and more.

Julie Menin

This is not at all in line with the testimony we heard from SpaceX AI that they're focused on safety.

Julie Menin

So I was very deeply disappointed and found their testimony.

Julie Menin

Not credible, and unacceptable.

Julie Menin

We were very pleased to be joined by Mr.

Julie Menin

Kim, and we thank him for his bravery and courage in coming forward, and everyone else who testified today.