Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Aaron Jacobs opposes 561-A and supports Intro 48

New York City Council · Oct 20, 2026 · starts 4:29:58 · 2 min 32 sec

Jacobs, a public-school teacher in the Bronx, says his students suffer asthma and smell exhaust in class. He argues 561-A would give corporate polluters a free pass and urges the Council to pass Intro 48 instead.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

I'm a teacher.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

I don't have to be that loud, but I'll use the mic.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

Good afternoon.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

My name is Aaron Jacobs.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

I've been a New York City public school teacher for the past 16 years, and I live in Manhattan.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

I teach ninth grade in the Bronx near Fordham.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

My school's neighborhood is hit very hard by heavy traffic all the time, and a huge number of my students suffer with asthma, and they miss school a lot throughout the year because of that.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

My classroom sits on the second floor, right on the front lines.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

Too often my students smell toxic exhaust in the room, and on these hot days we're stuck between sweating or breathing in fumes with the windows open.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

Air pollution, as you know, kills over 3,200 New Yorkers every year.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

For 50 years, city agencies failed to enforce anti-idling laws.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

The Citizen Air Complaint Program is the only thing that finally worked.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

I know it works because where I live on 36th and 5th in Madison, there is way less idlers than there were three years ago when I started doing this.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

It's difficult to find them at this point, to be honest.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

It used to be like all the time.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

Yeah, it's great.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

It actually works.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

So the program is doing its job.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

I testified today in strong opposition to Intro 561A, sponsored by Councilmember Gennaro, which relates to regulating engine idling and citizen complaint enforcement.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

This intro threatens to wipe out all of our progress and give a massive free pass to corporate polluters.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

Intro 561A legalizes diesel generation idling, a dirty practice that DEP and OATH have already ruled is illegal and unnecessary.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

It also cuts back.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

pay for everyday New Yorkers doing enforcement work, replacing the 50-year-old 25% award with a flat fee, which honestly kind of kills a lot of the incentive for some people, I would think.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

It squeezes everyday people reporting pollution the same way delivery apps squeeze gig workers.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

In my 16 years of teaching, I've always taught my students to question everything.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

So I asked the council today, who actually benefits from Intro 561A?

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

It's definitely not my students.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

So the problem is pollution, not the people reporting it.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

Please reject Intro 561A and instead pass Intro 48, sponsored by Councilmember Aviles, which translates the Citizen Air Complaint Program into designated citywide languages.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

Intro 48 opens up the program to non-English speakers so every New Yorker can help clean air.

James F. Gennaro

Thank you.

James F. Gennaro

Thank you all.

James F. Gennaro

This was good.

James F. Gennaro

And so I really appreciate everyone's input.

James F. Gennaro

And, you know, we go forward from here.

James F. Gennaro

And I'm a different guy from when I started this hearing.

James F. Gennaro

So thank you for all the input.

James F. Gennaro

Appreciate that.

Member of the Public - Aaron Jacobs

Thank you as well.