Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Alia Soomro of NYLCV supports 48 and 11-A but says 561-A is not ready

New York City Council · Oct 20, 2026 · starts 4:34:30 · 2 min 49 sec

Soomro says vehicle idling harms environmental justice neighborhoods near highways and warehouses. NYLCV supports Intro 48 and Intro 11-A, recommends more DEP and OATH resources, and says 561-A is not in the right place, especially its 30-minute school-bus idling allowance.

Member of the Public - Alia Soomro

Oh, okay.

Member of the Public - Alia Soomro

Can y'all hear me now?

James F. Gennaro

Yes, yes.

Member of the Public - Alia Soomro

Thanks.

Member of the Public - Alia Soomro

Good afternoon.

Member of the Public - Alia Soomro

My name is Alia Sumro, and I'm the Deputy Director for New York City Policy at the New York League of Conservation Voters.

Member of the Public - Alia Soomro

Thank you, Chair Gennaro and members of the committee for the opportunity to testify today.

Member of the Public - Alia Soomro

We're submitting longer written comments.

Member of the Public - Alia Soomro

So every day, thousands of drivers idle their trucks and cars, harming public health and increasing greenhouse gas emissions.

Member of the Public - Alia Soomro

Vehicle idling has detrimental cumulative health impacts, especially on environmental justice neighborhoods throughout the city, given the fact that many of these neighborhoods are located near peaker plants, highways, last mile warehouses, and other industrial facilities.

Member of the Public - Alia Soomro

The Citizens Air Complaint Program can be a useful tool to combat vehicle idling and improve air quality.

Member of the Public - Alia Soomro

To improve the program so that the benefits are shared equitably, NYLCV recommends that the submittal process and the interface are more accessible and user-friendly,

Member of the Public - Alia Soomro

more resources are devoted to DEP, an oath for staffing to process these complaints in a more efficient manner, and the city ramp up enforcement and collections of idling infractions.

Member of the Public - Alia Soomro

Additionally, we underscore the importance of working towards comprehensive solutions beyond this program, including but not limited to

Member of the Public - Alia Soomro

rolling out more neighborhood delivery and loading zones to avoid double and triple parking, utilizing more electric cargo delivery bikes, implementing marine freight delivery such as the Blue Highways program.

Member of the Public - Alia Soomro

And electrifying our school bus fleet.

Member of the Public - Alia Soomro

The city council passed a law several years ago, and we really need to ensure that law is implemented.

Member of the Public - Alia Soomro

And YLCV has the following thoughts on the bills being heard today.

Member of the Public - Alia Soomro

We support the passage of Intro 48 to make the program more accessible and equitable.

Member of the Public - Alia Soomro

We also support Intro 11A.

Member of the Public - Alia Soomro

And we urge the city to increase idling enforcement and accountability.

Member of the Public - Alia Soomro

And with that said, we don't think that Intro 561A is in the right place.

Member of the Public - Alia Soomro

For instance, we think that allowing school buses to idle for up to 30 minutes is not right.

Member of the Public - Alia Soomro

It's a little excessive.

James F. Gennaro

Time has expired.

Member of the Public - Alia Soomro

Yeah, we'd be happy to work with the council and other stakeholders to improve the program and get it in the right place.

James F. Gennaro

Thank you, Alia.

James F. Gennaro

As always, talk soon.

James F. Gennaro

Right.

James F. Gennaro

Bye-bye.

James F. Gennaro

Michael McFadden.

Council Staff

You may begin.

James F. Gennaro

We're going to jump down one.

James F. Gennaro

Nandini Ashta Kanasia.

Council Staff

You may begin.