Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Chris Hartman opposes 561-A and says necessary idling is already exempt

New York City Council · Oct 20, 2026 · starts 4:45:05 · 2 min 49 sec

Hartman says the real goal is simply to get drivers to turn off engines when not needed. He argues necessary uses are already exempt and that DEP, not the law, is the bottleneck.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

Good afternoon.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

I was in chambers waiting to testify but had to leave.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

I missed a good portion of the testimony after I left.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

I am strongly opposed to 561A.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

In my opinion, seeking to gut the citizen idling program.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

I don't want anybody to lose sight of the fact that what we're really just trying to do is to have people turn off their engines and they're not needed.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

It's that simple.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

No one receives a violation.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

if their engine is on for any necessary purpose, which we've heard some of.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

There's been a lot of misleading testimony about people being given violations when they had some legitimate reason.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

That simply does not occur.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

I wanted to talk about transfer of liability.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

To me, that's another non-issue.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

Red light cameras, speed cameras, and these violations, which to me are the same, they're camera violations, documented by camera, all issued based upon license plate, and that should remain the same.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

The DEP is really the source of the frustrations from so many people here.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

They're simply not performing their tasks as they should.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

And Oath is also fallen greatly behind, but the DEP is the real bottleneck.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

I've had tremendous frustration as a citizen trying to make things better for all of our New Yorkers breathing.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

And I'm constantly frustrated with the DEP's unwillingness to actually do this task as they should and as they actually require to do that now.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

Stifling.

Council Staff

Time has expired.

James F. Gennaro

Thank you very much for your good testimony.

James F. Gennaro

Next witness is Callie Hoyt.

Council Staff

You may begin.

James F. Gennaro

Callie Hoyt.

Council Staff

You may begin.

James F. Gennaro

All right, so then I'm present.

James F. Gennaro

Let's see it.

Council Staff

Sarah Craig.

Council Staff

Sarah Craig.

James F. Gennaro

Maybe get Sarah.