Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Sanchez asks how DOB classifies union vs non-union sites

New York City Council · Oct 21, 2026 · starts 1:45:17 · 1 min 58 sec

Sanchez asks what criteria DOB uses to classify sites as union or non-union, who reports it, and whether DOB verifies; Tigani says reporting is self-identification without third-party verification under Local Law 78 of 2017, and that the former Pfizer headquarters was an open or mixed shop with both union and non-union trades.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

DOB's construction incident reporting classifies sites as union or non-union.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Many sites, however, employ both union and non-union workers through different contractors and subcontractors, such as in the Pfizer partial collapse.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

What criteria does DOB use to classify a site as union or non-union?

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Is the classification...

Pierina Ana Sanchez

based on the general contractor, the share of union workers on the site, or the trade involved in the incident?

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Who reports the site's union status to DOB?

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Does DOB verify?

Pierina Ana Sanchez

And finally, would DOB classify the former Pfizer headquarters conversion in Midtown as a union or non-union site?

Ahmed Tigani

So as a result of Local Law 78 of 2017, which was worked on by both the agency and administration and the council,

Ahmed Tigani

a number of steps were created to make sure that we were capturing details of an incident.

Ahmed Tigani

I mentioned earlier that...

Ahmed Tigani

When there is an incident, people are required to report within three business days, and through that portal or that call, it is a self-identification, self-verification.

Ahmed Tigani

We do not do a third-party check on that verification, but that information is also available on our website, so we make it available to the public.

Ahmed Tigani

And there is a column specifically asking to verify.

Ahmed Tigani

non-union versus union.

Ahmed Tigani

As far as the Pfizer building, based on what we know, we understand it was an open shop or mixed shop site with both non-union and union trades that worked on that site.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Got it.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

So the only time that DOB learns whether a site is union or non-union is when there is an incident that is reported that answers the question.

Ahmed Tigani

That's correct.

Ahmed Tigani

Again, our priority is regardless of affiliation, we...

Ahmed Tigani

focus on the worker, the incident, the accident, and how to prevent it in the future.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Thank you.