Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Remarks

Council Member Aldebol explains vote on COPA and horse carriage bill

New York City Council · Oct 22, 2026 · starts 1:15:45 · 2 min 21 sec

Council Member Shirley Aldebol explains her vote in favor of COPA, emphasizing the importance of preserving existing affordable housing. She also explains her support for Intro 943A, ending the horse carriage industry, while calling for accountability on worker transition.

Shirley Aldebol

Permission to explain my vote?

Shaun Abreu

Permission granted.

Shirley Aldebol

Thank you, Majority Leader.

Shirley Aldebol

First, I want to congratulate Council Member Sandy Nurse on her incredible hard work,

Shirley Aldebol

coalition building, listening to the concerns of myself and others, and her perseverance in bringing COPA to a vote today.

Shirley Aldebol

We rightly spend a significant amount of time on City Council discussing and working on how to build more affordable housing, but preserving existing affordable housing is just as impactful and vital to tackling the housing crisis.

Shirley Aldebol

I'm excited to continue to work with this coalition, opportunities to expand affordable housing and not not-for-profit housing development organizations in the Bronx.

Shirley Aldebol

I'd also like to take a moment to explain my vote on Intro 943A, prohibiting the operation of horse-drawn cabs and establishing an industry transition plan.

Shirley Aldebol

This bill has a unique and challenging intersection of issues for me.

Shirley Aldebol

Fundamentally, I believe that it is time to end the horse carriage industry due to the consumer and worker protection risks that it poses, in addition to the animal welfare concerns that it raises.

Shirley Aldebol

Recent tragic incidences have reinforced the risks that both passengers and drivers face while navigating horse carriages on an increasingly busy road.

Shirley Aldebol

busy, unpredictable streets of New York City and Central Park.

Shirley Aldebol

I have a deep respect for workers and small business owners who have built their livelihood through the horse carriage business and the unions that fight for them.

Shirley Aldebol

Many have done this work for decades and come to it from a passion for animals and an interest in working with people.

Shirley Aldebol

I do appreciate the work of both Speaker Menon and Mayor Mamdani to incorporate transition planning commitments for affected workers and business owners into this legislation.

Shirley Aldebol

And I am optimistic that we will hold the administration accountable and ensure that the transition plans will include compensation.

Shaun Abreu

Thank you, Council Member.

Shirley Aldebol

Thank you.

Council Staff

Council member, eligible?

Shaun Abreu

I vote aye.

Council Staff

Thank you.

Council Staff

Ariola.