Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Remarks

Council Member Gennaro proposes amendment to extend horse carriage phase-out to 2030

New York City Council · Oct 22, 2026 · starts 0:27:44 · 3 min 31 sec

Council Member James Gennaro moves to amend Intro 943A to extend the effective date to January 1, 2030. He argues workers need more time to transition and that the bill lacks concrete commitments for their livelihoods.

Shaun Abreu

Thank you, Speaker Menon.

Shaun Abreu

We will now move into discussion of general orders.

Shaun Abreu

I recognize Councilmember Gennaro, who wishes to speak on some matters.

James F. Gennaro

Thank you, Mr.

James F. Gennaro

Majority Leader.

James F. Gennaro

I move to amend Intro 943A.

James F. Gennaro

I think the best description of the...

James F. Gennaro

Of the amendment I was told would come from the parliamentarian.

James F. Gennaro

If you could explain to the members what this amendment would do.

James F. Gennaro

I don't think the clock should be running until the amendment is explained to the members.

Shaun Abreu

Thank you, Council Member.

Shaun Abreu

Anyone else would like to speak on the amendment being proposed?

James F. Gennaro

But we don't know what it is yet.

Shaun Abreu

The motion to amend is the following.

Shaun Abreu

A yes will extend effective date to January 1st, 2030 as part of Section 17-327A2.

Shaun Abreu

And if we vote on this amendment, it will lay over Intro 943A for the next stated for a vote.

Shaun Abreu

A no vote will leave Intro 943A unchanged and we will vote on it today.

Shaun Abreu

Anyone who wishes, we can now go to roll call.

Shaun Abreu

Anyone who wishes to speak has two minutes to speak.

James F. Gennaro

But I speak for you.

Shaun Abreu

General, you may finish your time.

James F. Gennaro

Okay.

Shaun Abreu

Council member, my apologies.

James F. Gennaro

Thank you very much, Mr.

James F. Gennaro

Majority Leader.

James F. Gennaro

When we were listening to Father Kalilia, he made mention in his benediction, he talked about drivers working to make ends meet.

James F. Gennaro

That was part of his blessing.

James F. Gennaro

And I think, I don't think anyone wants to see the drivers in this good industry put upon in such a way that they will be unable to feed their families.

James F. Gennaro

And as the bill stands now, we would receive, or they would receive, the city would receive

James F. Gennaro

a document from the mayor, a plan that would take care of the disposition of the horses, the disposition of the workers into new jobs, and the disposition of the medallions.

James F. Gennaro

Understanding that, you know, the language associated with that is, will consider reimbursement, consider, it's a pig in a poke.

James F. Gennaro

Like, I get it.

James F. Gennaro

And so this is how it's playing out.

James F. Gennaro

The drivers were promised, the city was promised that...

James F. Gennaro

The program for the workers, for the drivers, for the medallion owners, to quote the speaker on 7-16-26, we need to do more to protect the workers.

James F. Gennaro

We're really trying to come up with more robust language, which I think needs to be inserted into that bill.

James F. Gennaro

That never actually happened.

James F. Gennaro

And so what I'm really asking for is if this thing comes out on April 1st like it's supposed to, then the industry's got 14 months to pack up because they don't know what is going to be in that.

James F. Gennaro

They don't know what's going to be in that report.

James F. Gennaro

And what I'm asking for is give them an extra 18 months to figure out their lives because they were supposed to have today what they need.

James F. Gennaro

So they know what's going to become of them.

James F. Gennaro

That won't exist at best until April 1st of 2001.

James F. Gennaro

Thank you, Mr.

James F. Gennaro

Majority Leader.