Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Abreu asks why CIS investigates only 200-250 crashes and whether it needs resources

New York City Council · Oct 27, 2026 · starts 1:06:27 · 3 min

Abreu asks why CIS investigates only about 200-250 crashes per year despite many serious crashes. Rivera reiterates CIS criteria, while Flynn acknowledges a gap between serious and critical injuries and says resources are not unlimited. Abreu offers to partner on obtaining more CIS resources.

Shaun Abreu

So CIS investigates about 200 to 250 crashes per year, despite there being many more crashes in our city that result in death and serious injury.

Shaun Abreu

Why is this number so low, and does CIS require more resources?

Philip Rivera

So the criteria, again, for CIS is this critical injuries, seriously likely to die or fatal.

Philip Rivera

Those are the cases that CIS will handle.

Philip Rivera

So what's the second half of the question?

Shaun Abreu

Despite there being many more crashes in our city that result in death and serious injury, why is this number so low?

Mike Flynn

Chair, I think, again, what I would point to is the space, perhaps, between a serious injury and what's designated as a critical injury.

Mike Flynn

I don't want to in any way take away from how life-affecting a crash can be and how serious injuries can be in those instances.

Mike Flynn

But the procedures that we have in place are for when that injury, that is a serious injury, crosses over to being a critical injury based on determinations that are made by EMS or at a hospital.

Mike Flynn

And those critical injuries are those instances where those fatalities are likely to be fatal, where we're going to have CIS take over an investigation.

Shaun Abreu

Do you believe that all hit-and-run cases should be placed under CIS investigation?

Mike Flynn

As I said earlier, Chair, and you might get sick of me saying it, but we are aware of the fact that we don't live in an instance where we have unlimited resources all the time.

Mike Flynn

And that's not necessarily just PD resources that we're talking about here.

Mike Flynn

A CIS investigation is a really intensive, extensive investigation that has widespread impact.

Mike Flynn

We use that process.

Mike Flynn

We use those resources in the most serious cases.

Mike Flynn

That's the process that we have available.

Mike Flynn

And that's not to take away from the investigation that goes on when CIS is not involved.

Mike Flynn

Those cases are going to a detective squad.

Mike Flynn

They are thoroughly investigated.

Shaun Abreu

And as I said earlier, I'm asking all these questions because I want to make sure that PD has the resources.

Shaun Abreu

resources.

Shaun Abreu

Do you need more officers for CIS?

Shaun Abreu

I mean, we want to make sure that the hit and runs are spiking.

Shaun Abreu

And we want to increase the identification rates.

Shaun Abreu

We want to increase the arrest rates.

Shaun Abreu

What do you need from us?

Shaun Abreu

What should we advocate for?

Mike Flynn

So, Sharon, I want to say three things here.

Mike Flynn

I think, first of all, I'd just reiterate, obviously, we would take everything that we can get in a perfect world.

Mike Flynn

Second, with respect to decisions about how to allocate resources, how to do assignments in the departments, that's something that we're constantly looking at, reevaluating and making new determinations on to shift resources where they're needed most.

Mike Flynn

And then third, with respect to upcoming budget, I mean, we'll be looking forward and the commissioner will be looking forward to being in touch with council about that process as we move into that process.

Shaun Abreu

And as we move into that process, I'm going to be looking for more enforcement on moving violations, CIS if you need more resources to beef up.

Shaun Abreu

You know, the pursuit of these hit and run drivers, you know, consider me a partner.