Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

David Bartner testifies as parent about dangerous streets

New York City Council · Oct 27, 2026 · starts 4:10:24 · 3 min 28 sec

David Bartner, a Brooklyn father of three, says dangerous driving happens daily near his home and a car with about 20 speeding tickets and Jersey plates nearly hit him. He says the danger is huge vehicles, not delivery bikes, and wants children to be able to bike independently.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

Hey, my name's David Bartner.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

I'm a father.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

I live in Brooklyn.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

I have three kids.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

Sorry, I don't know why I'm emotional, but every day someone does something dangerous in a car.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

Every day near our house.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

And there's no accountability.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

The other day I was almost hit by a car that had like 20 speeding tickets.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

And I had jersey plates.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

And that car's been looked up on How's My Driving like 10 times.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

It's absurd.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

This guy knows how to cross the street, but he can't because it's so dangerous.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

And that's why all parents don't let their five and six-year-olds cross the street on their own.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

That is no kind of a society.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

We have to be moving fast to allow our children to grow independently where the consequences of a mistake are not life and death.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

The danger is not delivery bikes, who have gotten a lot better, I would say, in the last couple of years on the streets.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

The danger are these huge vehicles.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

Who are making noise.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

Everything as small as making noise to wake these kids up from naps, to disturb our peaceful neighborhoods, to slaughtering our children for something as simple as riding a bike.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

I really want to ask the city is when he's 10 years old, he's six.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

When he's 10, will he be able to ride a bike to his friend's house on his own?

Member of the Public - David Bartner

Unfortunately, I think probably not.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

But that's a simple goal, and we should aspire to it.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

And anyone who's trying to get in our way is getting in our way.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

in the way of very simple progress that is attainable.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

We see it in other cities.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

We see it in other places.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

The reason parents don't let their kids do this stuff anymore is because in the 70s, in the 60s, look up the numbers of kids who died by cars.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

It was horrible.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

So parents started keeping their kids indoors.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

And go back in New York City history, you'll see protests from children, from mothers in the 40s and 50s.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

They gave up.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

And a lot of them left.

Member of the Public - David Bartner

Let's build streets for our workers, for our children, for joy and for beauty.

Shaun Abreu

Thank you for your heartfelt testimony.

Shaun Abreu

Government needs to do a lot, a lot more.

Shaun Abreu

But appreciate you taking your time and bringing your kids with you.

Shaun Abreu

We're doing it for them.

Shaun Abreu

Thank you.

Shaun Abreu

This panel is excused.

Shaun Abreu

Fakrul Hassan, Modi So, Jairi Castro, John Stephen, Bubakar Barry.

Shaun Abreu

As a reminder to please state your name before you speak.

Shaun Abreu

Thank you very much.