Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Francisco Insfran testifies on staff hostility and lack of safety

New York City Council · Oct 28, 2026 · starts 0:18:07 · 8 min 57 sec

Insfran, speaking in Spanish and English, says shelter staff are not trained to de-escalate, ignored his requests for a room key, and retaliated when he closed his door. He asks for basic respect and safety.

Crystal Hudson

And now we'll hear from Francisco Insfrain.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

Mi nombre es Francisco Insfran y soy miembro del colectivo de liderazgo comunitario de Coalición por Homeless.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

Gracias por la oportunidad que nos dan en esta audiencia.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

Esperaba encontrar estabilidad mientras trabajaba para conseguir una vivienda permanente.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

Es difícil lograr esa estabilidad cuando no me siento seguro en el albergue.

Member of the Public

Good afternoon.

Member of the Public

My name is Francisco Insfran.

Member of the Public

I'm a member of the Community Collective Coalition for Homeless.

Member of the Public

Thanks to all of you here in the hearing.

Member of the Public

I'm addressing to you because I don't feel safe in these homeless shelters.

Member of the Public

I was hoping to find stability while I was working to find a permanent home for me.

Member of the Public

But it's very difficult to find stability when I don't find myself safe in one of these homeless places.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

Uno de los aspectos más difíciles de vivir en un albergue es la forma en que tratan a los empleados de dieches.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

Se supone que ellos deben crear un entorno seguro para nosotros, sin embargo, cada vez que hay un conflicto entre ellos se crea un ambiente peligroso.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

En uno de los albergues en los que estuve se produjo una pelea entre el personal, el staff y un residente, porque el residente había pedido como un jugo extra.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

El personal sin capacidad respondió con hostilidad y desembocó en una gran pelea que hubo un gran destrozo en el shelter.

Member of the Public

One of the most difficult things or living in one of the homeless shelters is the way that the employees are treating the people who are living there in the shelter.

Member of the Public

We are supposed to have a very safe environment for all of us.

Member of the Public

However, we have a big conflict, and this is creating a very dangerous environment in the places where we live.

Member of the Public

In one of the homeless shelters I was living before, it was a very big fight.

Member of the Public

And the only reason of this big fight was that one of the homeless residents that lived there only asked...

Member of the Public

For an additional juice.

Member of the Public

This was the only thing that he asked.

Member of the Public

And only because asking for an additional juice, the person responded with hostility, right?

Member of the Public

And the person refused to give him the extra juice.

Member of the Public

And instead, to give him the juice was a very big fight between both of them.

Member of the Public

Continúa.

Member of the Public

Desde aquí ninguno hasta personal, ¿ok?

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

Ninguna de las otras personas hizo nada para ayudar en ese momento.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

Solo miraban o hacían que no entendían absolutamente nada.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

El destrozo fue grande.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

La pelea terminó y parte del equipamiento de la cocina quedó absolutamente destrozada.

Member of the Public

Any of the people who were working at the shelter did anything to try to help in the situation or to stack the fire, right?

Member of the Public

The only thing they were doing, they were looking at them at the same time they were fighting without doing anything, right?

Member of the Public

And the fire was so bad that it even destroyed some of the kitchen utensils and some of the kitchen equipment that was there.

Member of the Public

And why we should have this cruel reaction from these people from the homeless shelters.

Member of the Public

Vas a ir de las, la tercera página.

Member of the Public

¿Lo pueden ver?

Member of the Public

Las con el que.

Member of the Public

¿Puedes, verdad?

Member of the Public

Sí.

Member of the Public

Ok, tranquilo.

Member of the Public

Los personal no están entrenados.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

O sea, el personal, disculpa, de staff, no está entrenada realmente para crear un ambiente tranquilo y que pueda ser seguro para los residentes.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

Especialmente cuando vives en un albergue para personas solas con una alta población.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

También me preocupa que sucede si sufro maltrato o soy testigo en la situación insegura.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

Prefiero no decir nada para no empeorar mi situación.

Member of the Public

I believe this homeless staff, right, is not well trained.

Member of the Public

They are not trained enough to create, like I say, environment in these homeless shelters, especially when you live in a homeless shelter and you are there by yourself.

Member of the Public

You are alone, right, with a very high population, right?

Member of the Public

Something I'm very concerned that I should maybe suffer mistreatment from these people in the homeless shelter, or it could be also a weakness or a very insecure situation or unsafe situation that will happen there.

Member of the Public

There are moments where I prefer not to say anything because I think if I say something, it will make my situation worse than before.

Member of the Public

Okay, now we're going to go here.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

Yo personalmente recibo.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

En una unidad especializada para personas con discapacidad.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

Sin embargo, el personal no me proporciona una llave para mi unidad.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

Llave del apartamento.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

Sí.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

Y cuando sigo pidiendo uno, el personal, en vez de ayudarme, me ignora.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

Ok.

Member of the Public

Ok.

Member of the Public

I'm living and I'm residing in a specialized unit for people who suffer from incapacities or discapacities, right?

Member of the Public

However, the people who are there never provide me with a house key or a room key, right, in the place where I'm living.

Member of the Public

And every time when I'm requesting a key from this homeless status, homeless employees, what they are doing to me, they're just ignoring me, you know?

Member of the Public

Desde aquí ni siquiera hasta...

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

Ni siquiera puedo cerrar mi puerta cuando voy a ver a mis hijos.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

El personal se enfada conmigo cuando cierro la puerta porque entonces tienen que buscar a un guardia especial para que me abra la puerta.

Member of the Public

Ok.

Member of the Public

You know, the situation is so bad that I cannot even close my door, you know, the room door, because sometimes I go outside to see my children.

Member of the Public

My children don't live in the homeless shelter.

Member of the Public

They live outside.

Member of the Public

The personal staff becomes very angry with me because I'm closing the door, and what they are doing to me, they are sending a security guard to open the door, right?

Member of the Public

Instead, you know, to keep the door closed, okay?

Member of the Public

Okay.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

En este caso yo no estoy pidiendo un trato especial.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

Pido el respeto básico y la seguridad que toda persona merece.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

Entiendo que vivir en un albergue puede ser difícil, pero eso no significa que debamos aceptar condiciones que hacen nuestras vidas mucho más estresantes y nos hacen sentir inseguros.

Member of the Public

I'm not asking for a special treatment from the homeless shelter.

Member of the Public

No, that's not my intention.

Member of the Public

I'm only asking for a basic respect, and also I'm asking to have safety in that place.

Member of the Public

I believe every person that lives in a homeless shelter deserves any type of safety, right?

Member of the Public

I completely understand that living in a homeless shelter could be very difficult for everyone, but this doesn't mean that we should accept these conditions of those people

Member of the Public

that are going to make our life more stressful and are going to make our life more insecure while we're living in those homeless shelters.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

Un refugio debería ser un lugar donde pueda encontrar estabilidad, no otro sitio donde deba preocuparme por mi seguridad.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

Todos merecemos un lugar seguro donde alojarnos y una oportunidad real para salir adelante.

Member of the Public

I believe a homeless shelter should be a place where we could find stability.

Member of the Public

It should not be a place where I have to be worried about my safety myself.

Member of the Public

All of us, even we're poor, we're homeless, we deserve a safe place to live, right?

Member of the Public

Like a secure place and also a safe place where we can stay without worrying about anything and we should have a real opportunity to move forward in the future.

Member of the Public

Okay, that's everything.