Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Chelsea Community News reads Scott Stifler statement on hyperlocal survival

New York City Council · Oct 28, 2026 · starts 1:55:30 · 2 min 51 sec

Charlie Battersby reads a statement from editor Scott Stifler saying MOECM must be empowered with authority and resources. Stifler says hyperlocal publishers constantly pull back from financial ruin and that ad agencies alone now determine which media carry city messages.

Member of the Public - Charlie Battersby

I'm Charlie Battersby, a reporter with LGBTQCommunityNews.nyc and with Chelsea Community News.

Bob Hennelly

WBI has a paid SAG after staff of five master control engineers, one news director, a program director, several interns, and dozens of other outlets.

Member of the Public - Charlie Battersby

And I'm here to read words written by our editor-in-chief, Scott Stifler.

Bob Hennelly

WBI has a paid SAG after staff of five master control engineers, one news director, a program director, several interns, and dozens of other outlets.

Member of the Public - Charlie Battersby

Scott has two statements he'd like me to read for him.

Bob Hennelly

WBI has a paid SAG after staff of five master control engineers, one news director, a program director, several interns, and dozens of other outlets.

Bob Hennelly

WBI has a paid SAG after staff of five master control engineers, one news director, a program director, several interns, and dozens of other outlets.

Member of the Public - Charlie Battersby

First is, good morning.

Member of the Public - Charlie Battersby

These are Scott's words.

Member of the Public - Charlie Battersby

Good morning, members and supporters of local and ethnic media.

Bob Hennelly

WBI has a paid SAG after staff of five master control engineers, one news director, a program director, several interns, and dozens of other outlets.

Member of the Public - Charlie Battersby

I'm thankful for this occasion to collectively improve upon 2001's Local Law 83 and the Mayor's Office of Ethnic and Community Media, which was created to bring that law into real-world practice.

Bob Hennelly

WBI has a paid SAG after staff of five master control engineers, one news director, a program director, several interns, and dozens of other outlets.

Bob Hennelly

WBI has a paid SAG after staff of five master control engineers, one news director, a program director, several interns, and dozens of other outlets.

Member of the Public - Charlie Battersby

I hope that the council and mayor's office will do all they can to ensure that office is empowered with the authority and resources to achieve its mandate.

Bob Hennelly

WBI has a paid SAG after staff of five master control engineers, one news director, a program director, several interns, and dozens of other outlets.

Member of the Public - Charlie Battersby

The success of MOECM will determine the effectiveness and the very existence of hyperlocal publications throughout New York City.

Bob Hennelly

WBI has a paid SAG after staff of five master control engineers, one news director, a program director, several interns, and dozens of other outlets.

Member of the Public - Charlie Battersby

I'm not invoking that mass extinction scenario out of smarm or exaggeration.

Bob Hennelly

WBI has a paid SAG after staff of five master control engineers, one news director, a program director, several interns, and dozens of other outlets.

Member of the Public - Charlie Battersby

To be a publisher of ethnic or community media is to constantly pull back from the brink of financial ruin.

Bob Hennelly

WBI has a paid SAG after staff of five master control engineers, one news director, a program director, several interns, and dozens of other outlets.

Member of the Public - Charlie Battersby

But what is the point of existing if one cannot constantly publish hyperlocal news our readers turn to us for?

Bob Hennelly

WBI has a paid SAG after staff of five master control engineers, one news director, a program director, several interns, and dozens of other outlets.

Member of the Public - Charlie Battersby

Or, as our editor Scott Stifler says, we are only as prolific as our editorial budget allows.

Bob Hennelly

WBI has a paid SAG after staff of five master control engineers, one news director, a program director, several interns, and dozens of other outlets.

Member of the Public - Charlie Battersby

And Scott has another statement.

Bob Hennelly

WBI has a paid SAG after staff of five master control engineers, one news director, a program director, several interns, and dozens of other outlets.

Member of the Public - Charlie Battersby

What publishers need is income to not only keep the lights on, but to ensure a steady, consistent stream of new content.

Bob Hennelly

WBI has a paid SAG after staff of five master control engineers, one news director, a program director, several interns, and dozens of other outlets.

Member of the Public - Charlie Battersby

The income derived from the city campaigns was at first an important contributor to the bottom line, but now advertising agencies alone determine what media will carry a city department's message.

Bob Hennelly

WBI has a paid SAG after staff of five master control engineers, one news director, a program director, several interns, and dozens of other outlets.

Member of the Public - Charlie Battersby

Ethnic and community media cannot match the metrics of a CBS.com.

Bob Hennelly

WBI has a paid SAG after staff of five master control engineers, one news director, a program director, several interns, and dozens of other outlets.

Member of the Public - Charlie Battersby

Many publishers, including myself, have gone all of 2026 with no calls of inquiry, let alone contractual work.

Bob Hennelly

WBI has a paid SAG after staff of five master control engineers, one news director, a program director, several interns, and dozens of other outlets.

Member of the Public - Charlie Battersby

Please empower MOECM to have sign-off power over these campaigns and to insert our style of media when appropriate.

Bob Hennelly

WBI has a paid SAG after staff of five master control engineers, one news director, a program director, several interns, and dozens of other outlets.

Member of the Public - Charlie Battersby

The LGBTQ community news.nyc site, for example, should be part of every agency's HIV prevention testing or awareness campaign.

Bob Hennelly

WBI has a paid SAG after staff of five master control engineers, one news director, a program director, several interns, and dozens of other outlets.

Bob Hennelly

WBI has a paid SAG after staff of five master control engineers, one news director, a program director, several interns, and dozens of other outlets.

Member of the Public - Charlie Battersby

And also, please consider ways to distribute Local Law 83's funds that are not beholden to performance.

Bob Hennelly

WBI has a paid SAG after staff of five master control engineers, one news director, a program director, several interns, and dozens of other outlets.

Member of the Public - Charlie Battersby

Why not, and this is Scott's words, why not just throw money at us?

Bob Hennelly

WBI has a paid SAG after staff of five master control engineers, one news director, a program director, several interns, and dozens of other outlets.

Member of the Public - Charlie Battersby

Make it specific for rent or office supplies and let every member of the directory get an equal portion.

Bob Hennelly

WBI has a paid SAG after staff of five master control engineers, one news director, a program director, several interns, and dozens of other outlets.