Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Public Testimony

Kiara Sakiheld Testimony: Lower East Side Resident

New York City Council · Apr 23, 2025 · starts 3:24:44 · 2 min 30 sec

Kiara Sakiheld, a Lower East Side resident, testifies via Zoom in favor of outdoor dining as a crucial public health accommodation for immunocompromised individuals.

Member of the Public - Kiana

The subtext of the opposition to outdoor dining is that it was a COVID era program, but because COVID is over, the program should be curtailed and our streets should be returned to cars.

Member of the Public - Kiana

But COVID is still very real for many New Yorkers.

Member of the Public - Kiana

And if you're concerned about ADA violations, please remember that disability can take many forms.

Member of the Public - Kiana

And I'm very concerned that being high risk or immunocompromised has been entirely overlooked in this conversation.

Member of the Public - Kiana

It's not lost on me that the city's own rules for in-person testimony today include COVID safety protocols like masking that don't seem to be widely adopted or enforced, which serves as a visible reminder for how vulnerable people are further excluded from public life.

Member of the Public - Kiana

Vanishing outdoor dining options are particularly troubling when Kathy Hochel is pushing for a statewide mask ban.

Member of the Public - Kiana

Vaccine uptake is terrible.

Member of the Public - Kiana

COVID cases surged last summer.

Member of the Public - Kiana

The CDC is cutting billions in funds to help state to health departments respond to COVID.

Member of the Public - Kiana

And Gotham has recently reported that 500,000 New Yorkers have long COVID, which can be so debilitating it prevents them from being able to work and support themselves.

Member of the Public - Kiana

Every new COVID case is a new opportunity for one of our neighbors to get seriously ill, die, or experience long-term complications.

Member of the Public - Kiana

Outdoor dining also plays a role in stopping the spread of flu, and this year flu cases were at their highest level since 2020.

Member of the Public - Kiana

There have been 23 pediatric deaths statewide this season, nine of which were here in the city.

Member of the Public - Kiana

Proper ventilation is crucial to preventing airborne illness, but the city has not invested in the infrastructure needed to make indoor dining safer.

Member of the Public - Kiana

And most outdoor dining options aren't even available year-round, meaning that if you're vulnerable, you can't safely or easily participate in a huge piece of public and social life for half the year.

Member of the Public - Kiana

With all of this in mind, I'm asking the council to please make applying for roadside and sidewalk seating less cumbersome, allow year-round streeteries, and provide more flexibility for sidewalk cafes.

Member of the Public - Kiana

Outdoor dining is a public good, particularly when it comes to public health.

Member of the Public - Kiana

Thank you so much.

Julie Menin

Thank you.

Julie Menin

Next speaker, please.

Council Staff

You may begin.

Julie Menin

Michelle Campo, are you able to testify?